Album Rating: 5.0
This is my 4th favourite pumpkins album (behind siamese dream, gish, judas 0), maybe 3rd equal with judas, but i still give it 5/5.
2 of my all tiem fav's are on here (thru the eyes of ruby and porcelina). I would also give x.y.u. a 10/10, its such a powerful song, and i usually dont like heavy songs but for some reason i love that one.
|
| |
As a side note, I really wish they would have included "Ugly". It's really one of my favorite Pumpkins songs, although it focuses mostly on Billy, not the band.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
[QUOTE=AKid2]As a side note, I really wish they would have included "Ugly". It's really one of my favorite Pumpkins songs, although it focuses mostly on Billy, not the band.[/QUOTE]
Yeah, SP should've replaced Tales of a Scorched Earth with Ugly or God even.
I'd rather replace it with God though because it's an angry song and it'd fill the spot of Tales of a Scorched Earth better.
|
| |
Ugly is great. /gets Ugly stuck in head
|
| |
there arenīt many bands that could equal what the smashing pumpkins have done, specially in the new scene, mellon collie is a masterpiece and one of the best albums ever in my opinion, i dont think this band is overrated at all, siamese dream is also a great record.
good review :thumb:
|
| |
Holy crap, i listened to the second disc through and all the tracks i used to dislike (By starlight, farewell and goodnight, in the arms of sleep, beautiful) are all great songs. I guess that shows my passive attitude...
|
| |
iv been getting to all the songs on this cd, recently its been the hard songs like Jellybelly, an ode to no one, where boys fear to thread, tales of a scorced earth, and X. Y. U. dont know why but the harder side of the pumpkins is catching me lately. and cause its awesome to learn on guitar.
|
| |
Excellent review! I really don't mind Corgan's voice, although I think it can be a tad agrivating. Still, the instrumentals work excellently so it works out.
|
| |
I prefer siamese dream to this album
|
| |
Yeh Siamese Dream is my favourite album. Tales of a Schorched earth has some value, disagree? Thought so.
Still, it ceases to amaze me that Ugly and The Boy never made this album. The Boy was such a great song, should of been on here. Was tonite reprise related to Tonight Tonight by any chance?
|
| |
billy corgan is a faggot on a stick
|
| |
Idiot.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
this album has some classic songs, i can play it and just get lost in the music. it really makes me forget about all my problems and just listen to music. really good album.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
nice review but "Siamese Dream" will always be my favorite smashing pumpkins album
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
almost as good as siamese. But seriously, i like we only come out at night... it's really and individual song.
good review, if only it was a whole one...
|
| |
only listened to dawn to dusk and i really liked it, il hav 2 c wat twightlight to staright is like
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
one of his favorite albums of all-time
writes a 3.5 review about it
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5
revives 7 year old thread
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off
one of his favorite albums of all-time
writes a 3.5 review about it
This
|
| |
|
|
