Album Rating: 5.0

Ya, what's with all the 33 hate? It's wicked catchy.

Meh I think 33 is one of the worst songs too. And I keep trying to see why so many people rate this a 5, and the other Coheed albums I have (IKSSE: 3 & GAIMS 4) are so much more solid IMO. This album is awesome, but it's too samey all the way through for me to give it anything higher than a 4.

Album Rating: 4.0

I agree that their other albums are better.



33 is a good song, though.

Album Rating: 5.0

I associate this album with an old flame - one of my personal favourite albums that resonates deeply.

Album Rating: 4.5

Well put. Coheed have been consistently great for most of their history but this... I have no words for some of these songs. Time Consumer and Delirium trigger this elusive sense of melancholy in me. Suffice to say, as a fan of the former I also love 21:13.

By the way, I've just read your review for the first time, so... accept this late "you nailed it".