No MM8, regardless of opinions the fact is that the music is literally not of a high caliber. Who it appeals to and what saverity is when opinions come into play.

No, your opinion is that they're not of a high caliber. Anyone could easily argue that as Atreyu's career progresses they continue to show vast improvements in the musical department and while the screaming is terrible, then clean vocals are fine, so all they need to do, really, is find a better screamer and they're on easy streak.

That, of course, isn't my opinion on the band. I'm just making the point that it could easily be argued that Atreyu don't suck. Thusly, it's not fact that they suck, it's your above and despite a couple mild exagerations, they wouldn't be wrong.This Message Edited On 07.27.07

I wouldn't say mild, maybe vast or magnanimous.

nvms!This Message Edited On 07.28.07

Album Rating: 1.5

metallicaman8, who posted a few posts above yours.

Album Rating: 3.0

This has got to be one of the most controversial bands in metalcore history. I have to say though, the melodies on this album is catchy sometimes.

'Controversial'? I'd say 'worst'.

Album Rating: 1.5

There's worse, but this still sucks so yeah maybe

Worst in metalcore or worst in general? I was referring to metalcore.

Album Rating: 1.5

Both are the same to me really tbqh minus like 4-5 bands.

Album Rating: 1.0

yay 1500 posts for me too

Tribestos you soft ass nigga

I cant rate this its not worth it