Album Rating: 4.2

Character and this destroy post-Clayman.

On the otherhand, Clayman and In Flames' previous works > any Dark Tranquillity.

Album Rating: 4.5

Not really. In Flames is my favorite band but The Gallery is superior to Clayman even if I like it. DT and In Flames are 2 great band. but DT now>>>>>>>>>InFlames now.

Album Rating: 3.0

Wow, this is some crazy debate but Im going to have to say that Clayman is one of my all time favourite albums. Character and the one song I heard from Fiction are amazing, but Clayman just has the essense of a band who really found their sound at the time. But Dark Tranquility has consistency and hasnt really progressed too fast (if it aint broke, dont fix it)..................fuck now Im just on the fence with this one.

^^^^^Now this motherfucker knows what he's talking about! Clayman's my favorite album all time, along with Rust In Peace, so maybe I'm a bit biased...

Album Rating: 4.0

Dark Tran > In Flames imo, even though i've know in flames much longer.



I think this and character are better than every album by In Flames, except maybe

colony. In Fact, i'll do my best to list every dt and if album in order from my fav to

least fav. Ones not included i don't own.



character

fiction (still can't really decide, but im going with character because of "lost to

apathy")

colony (these top three are really close)

Jester Race

Clayman

Damage Done

The Gallery

Whoracle

Projector

Come Clarity

R2R

Lunar Strain



Yeah, i only own 5 Dark tran so far, and 7 IF. Other than the last three on those 12

albums, each of them are amazing, and very close together. Dark Tanquillity and In

Flames are both amazing bands.This Message Edited On 04.25.07

Arghhh, blasphemy. Oh well, no use arguing, they are both great bands. But Come Clarity is a great album, and putting it under R2R... no.

Album Rating: 4.0

That was a mistake, i like it better than R2R. I'll edit it now.

Album Rating: 4.2

I really like Clayman. It's probably my second favourite from In Flames. Anyways I'd have:



The Jester Race

Character

Fiction

Clayman

The Gallery

Colony

Whoracle

Luner Strain

Projector

Come Clarity

Reroute to Remain

Soundtrack to Your Escape



Obviously, I haven't heard all of Dark Tranquillity's albums, but whatever.This Message Edited On 04.25.07

OK, if I must.

Clayman
The Jester Race
Character
Fiction/The Gallery (can't decide)
Colony
Damage Done
Whoracle
Haven
Come Clarity
Skydancer/Of Chaos and Eternal Night
Projector
Reroute To Remain
Soundtrack To Your Escape

Might've left some out, but these are the important ones.

Album Rating: 4.0

All you left out were lunar strain by IF and Minds I by DT, but both aren't spectacular (i havent heard minds i but the so ngs i;ve heard from it sem lackluster compared to most DT)

Left out Lunar Strain and Subterranean cuz they had Mikael on vocals, and I don't have the Minds I so it would be wrong to judge it.

hmm... i've heard that this band sounds like Opeth? if they do i might check them out.

I like Opeth for their melodic guitar riffs... wonder if DT is like that as well.

Album Rating: 4.5

I wonder why you guys are leaving out Hypocrisy, Arch Enemy, At The Gates and other such bands...

Album Rating: 4.5

Well I guess I should list em too:



The Gallery -- DT

Skydancer/Of Chaos And Eternal Night -- DT

The Jester Race -- IF

The Mind's I -- DT

Fiction -- DT

Whoracle -- IF

Colony -- IF

Damage Done -- DT

Character -- DT

Clayman -- IF

Haven -- DT

Come Clarity -- IF

Projector -- DT

Exposures: In Retrospect And Denial -- DT

Soundtrack To Your Escape -- IF

Reroute To Remain -- IF



Well there's my two cents.... DT > IF

Album Rating: 3.0

I will give my favourite list when I hear Fiction!

Shattered_Future, give the album a chance. It's not supposed to sink in right away. Misery's Crown is just meant to be melodic and really dreamy, at least that's the way I hear it. To call the track "lame" is going a bit far (you do have a Kamelot avatar :p)

(I like Kamelot)

Album Rating: 3.5

how does this stack up to Character?? cause i loved Character but im not sure about this one.

Album Rating: 4.0

i cannot decide whether this surpasses character or not...

Album Rating: 4.2

They're pretty much equal. I prefer Character, but not by muchThis Message Edited On 04.29.07