Album Rating: 4.0

dark side has no filler, this has seamus

Album Rating: 4.5

Echoes is better than pretty much everything. But even when disregarding Seamus, Dark Side is stronger as an album. Few things can match the way that thing works as a whole.

Album Rating: 4.5

Seamus is mostly the reason why this isn't a 5 for me

Dark Side is definitely the more consistent out of the two but I love Echoes, Fearless and One of These Days so much that it's hard to choose between them.

This doesn't have the atmosphere that Animals, WYWH and Dark Side has imo, still a great album

Haven't really given this as much chance as I should've, got to change that soon

Album Rating: 4.5

Echoes doesn't have better atmosphere whaaaat?

Well echoes rules obviously, but I don't think it's above other PF epics really. Tbh it's been quite a while since I last heard this so I'll say more after a relisten haha

Dogs and Echoes are pretty much tied as my favourite Floyd songs.

Album Rating: 4.5

maybe better but it's okay if you think the "big 4" is better, that's a quite general opinion

Album Rating: 4.5

"Dogs and Echoes are pretty much tied as my favourite Floyd songs."



those two, Comfortably Numb, SOYCD and Pigs are my favorites

I still hold this above The Wall heh

Echoes I'd say is just behind Dogs for me for fave Floyd song.

and this is easily better than the wall.

Album Rating: 4.5

ugh fuck off man the wall is best



no but seriously, The Wall is their best imo even though most people here don't seem to love it as much

I've never liked the wall barring a few songs.

Well yeah it's great but WYWH is almost perfect for me, hard to top

Album Rating: 4.5

WYWH is a close second for me, near perfect agreed

WYWH is the one floyd album u should 5 imo.

those two, Comfortably Numb, SOYCD and Pigs are my favorites