shit if neutralthunder agrees with me then i guess you must be right crysis, im sorry for doubting you

Album Rating: 4.8

I can't just listen to a song or two on any Agalloch albums. I have to listen to the whole thing.

Album Rating: 5.0

12345678

Album Rating: 4.5

you are forgiven Scream



But seriously I thought this was an unquestioned 5 for the longest time (just look at my review) until this past summer when The Mantle smacked me across the face more than any other album in the history of forever.

Hawks hit the nail right on the head, but Crysis is right too. The Mantle and Pale Folklore are more cohesive, even though i can still listen to individual songs.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Mantle is the weakest of their LP's imo

Album Rating: 4.8

The Mantle is still their weakest IMO. Though that's not saying much because it's still easily a 4.5.

Album Rating: 4.5

That's what I thought too for like four years but suddenly wham and the mantle is pure brilliance

Album Rating: 4.8

They're all pure brilliance.

relistening to the mantle now. its always been by far their weakest for me although still good. I never got why some people hold it as highly as they do though cause i always seem to lose focus near the end. I still think its great but im impatiently waiting for it to just click fully

I'd go with Ashes, Pale Folklore (that's hard though, those really are the same level of awesome) and then The Mantle in close third.

Album Rating: 4.5

cause i always seem to lose focus near the end.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

too much filler on The Mantle. Not there's anything wrong with interludes and shorter songs, but the filler itself is just booooooring and even a few of the longer songs just get kinda meh. Maybe a 4, because its still fucking Agalloch, but it might not even be that high for me

Album Rating: 4.8

My favorite Agalloch song is still Falling Snow followed closely by Dead Winter Days and As Embers Dress the Sky.

FIRE

ABOVE

ICE

BELOW



or gtfo

Album Rating: 5.0

Bloodbirdz dood.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

those are allllll great songs. My faves are Not Unlike the Waves, Fire Above Ice Below, Hallways of Enchanted Ebony and Dead Winter Days. You Were But a Ghost in My Arms and Falling Snow are also up there

FIRE

ABOVE

ICE

BELOW [2]

But, Falling Snow is amazing, and Dead Winter Days.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

oh and Bloodbirds is also amazing. Im trying to get into the more applauded songs from The Mantle like The Hawthorne Passage and the 14 minute epic in the beginning, but I cant seem to enjoy them on the level that I enjoy my other favorite Agalloch songs

Album Rating: 4.5

Best Agalloch song is In the Shadow of Our Pale Companion.