i know, that guy is an idiot anyway. but lets get back on track
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
Acey you're a genius. Frances (heyseuss) was being sarcastic towards you. Mudvaynian commented on that. Wow.
Actually, I think I'm going t do it. Nirvana > Metallica.
|
| |
damn (shakes fist in joking manner, than walks away while Bron chases after me to beat me down)
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Actually, I think I'm going t do it. Nirvana > Metallica.
Meh, Kurt Cobain was a good song writer, but lacked quality in virtually all other fields (vocals, instrumentation). So, while the songwriting may be on par with Metallica I think Metallica would win in pertty much every other category, but that's just me. Bron is entitled to his opinion guys, so let's not give him too much grief.
Bronathan dearest, if you have the time go skim through my Megadeth review would you?
|
| |
Meh, Kurt Cobain was a good song writer, but lacked quality in virtually all other fields (vocals
Ha!
Ahhaha!
Ahhahahahaha!
HAHAHAAAAA
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
Meh, Kurt Cobain was a good song writer, but lacked quality in virtually all other fields (vocals, instrumentation).
Agreed, though I rather like his vocals sometimes. Sometimes they suck. But honestly from what I've seen/heard, Kurt was more on top of the game with vocals than James.
So, while the songwriting may be on par with Metallica
This is false. They are ABOVE Metallica with songwriting. Far, far above. Metallica is better with technicality and such, but showing off really that only takes you so far when your goal is to entertain.
Bronathan dearest, if you have the time go skim through my Megadeth review would you?
Checking.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Agreed, though I rather like his vocals sometimes. Sometimes they suck. But honestly from what I've seen/heard, Kurt was more on top of the game with vocals than James.
Depends what era of Metallica you're talking about IMO.
This is false. They are ABOVE Metallica with songwriting. Far, far above. Metallica is better with technicality and such, but showing off really that only takes you so far when your goal is to entertain.
I disagree, but am not in the mood to debate, so I'll just throw a meaningless cliche out there. Different strokes for different folks.
|
| |
add -if you know what i mean - to the end of that last sentance MM8
i know i am bad, but i wont do that again (laughs mockingly at what i just said)This Message Edited On 08.28.06
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
It's not that funny, Acey. Put your head down in shame.
|
| |
oh, oooooooookkkkkkkkk.....
p.s. you did set me up perfectly for that though, but i really wont do that again.
i also agree with everything else here said, but to me, metallica puts it to better use than nirvanaThis Message Edited On 08.28.06
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
Yeah dude fosho definitely Metallica's the best
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Correct, I did set you up. Unfortunately your execution was deplorable.
|
| |
it's like i could play for BYU, or some other horrible football school
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Kurt was good... not great. The 'semi-god' he's become is still amazing to me as to why since he isn't above... nore even that extraordinary. I like Nirvana, but to me the reason they hold him to such high regards or esteem is still lost to me. I bet someone will post "the same could go for Metallica," and that is true seeing as Metallica has become an extraordinarily mega popular band, and as far as to say some think they are overrated. I guess it's who you ask since I think Metallica are the best.
Still, I don't think Kurt's lyrics were better than what James' has written. Kurt spoke metaphorically but most was melancholy and bland as for James's has diversity in his lyrics ranging from whatever they found in the Bible to books that have inspired them. I bet I've left myself open to harsh comments about how stupid or how much of a douche or whatever but meh, f*** it. I've said what I've wanted to say.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Everyone seems to bag on The Thing That Should Not Be...that's so wrong. I love that song so much. It's so crushing!
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
[quote=El Goodo]...There were no solo's on St. Anger.[/quote]
/Generic guitar solo analysis
[quote=Metallicaman8]Correct, I did set you up. Unfortunately your execution was deplorable.[/quote]
*applause sign flashes*
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
I'm a Nirvana fan, I admit it. However, I am being completely neutral in my analysis when I say Kurt was a far superior lyricist than James ever was/will be.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
I'm a Nirvana fan, I admit it. However, I am being completely neutral in my analysis when I say Kurt was a far superior lyricist than James ever was/will be.
I donno about that one. A lot of Kurts lyrics made no sense. Like for example in Nirvana's most popular track "Smells Like Ten Spirity"
A mulato
An albino
A mosquito
My Labito
Yeah!
That's just not good.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
You really need to look deeper in Kurts lyrics, especially in In Utero before you make accusations on his lyrics.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
[quote=Bron-Yr-Aur]I'm a Nirvana fan, I admit it. However, I am being completely neutral in my analysis when I say Kurt was a far superior lyricist than James ever was/will be.[/quote]
Wasn't Cobain the main songwriter for Nirvana? James almost always collabs with Lars on lyrics with Kirk mumbling in the corner. Besides, the finished product Mehtallica puts out is not up to par with Nirvana's stuff. Somebody shoot me down, here.
|
| |
|
|
