Album Rating: 5.0

Of all time? For me top 💯. Uh,,, top 75 most likely, top 50? Ehhhh, maybe. Definitely not in the top 15 I’m sure of that tho. Not even sure this is their best album when I listen to The Changing of Times, Cries of The Past, others. This band overall tho? Erase Me can’t hurt their legacy it just doesn’t get counted for me.

Album Rating: 5.0

im ngl stuck between this and disambiguation for best underoath, none of the dallas albums hit for me the way the 2006-2010 run does. erase me is prolly the weakest spencer era record realistically but i have a connection with it still, as most of you are well aware

Album Rating: 5.0

Underoath probably has 3 top 100 all time albums and is a top 25 overall band.

Album Rating: 5.0

Disambiguation was once my fav Underoath album for about two years. Haven’t listened to it in a long time. In fact I’ve listened to Cries of the Past 6 times since the last time I heard ø

Album Rating: 5.0

in fact i actually love disambig for the exact reason it turned me off at first, it was too much, it was dark, moody, and oppressive as hell, and now that's why i love it. that's the exact same process converge had for me really.

feel like this is objectively their best. Not only for uo heads but i mean it received the most critical acclaim w the grammys and all that.. inspired the sound that literally shaped the genre itself for a few years.. was the album that really cemented their sound.. ya.

That said though, I think Disambig’s the better of the two personally, but it’s hard to ignore DTGL’s accolades

Def think this is their best but they're all pretty close pre-hiatus imo i.e the 3 Spencer albums after TOCS

Album Rating: 4.5

Disambiguation is the best and it's no contest for me

ya it’s a beaut for sure—it honestly just depends on yr metrics for ‘best’

Album Rating: 5.0

This > Disam > LITSOS > TOCS > CoT > who cares

Album Rating: 4.5

Honestly past couple years for me it's just Disam > this > litsos > who cares lol

Album Rating: 5.0

This and LITSOS are about tied for me. I think Spencer's screams are stronger here, and I love how well they blended the heavy with the poppy stuff. LITSOS has some moments that are almost as heavy as Aaron.

Album Rating: 5.0

I'm still a sucker for their early 2000's stuff, TOCS especially. But yeah both albums did not age very well.

Album Rating: 5.0

ur not into TOCS anymore steak?

Album Rating: 5.0

Of all time? For me top 💯. Uh,,, top 75 most likely, top 50? Ehhhh, maybe. Definitely not in the top 15 I’m sure of that tho. Not even sure this is their best album when I listen to The Changing of Times, Cries of The Past, others. This band overall tho? Erase Me can’t hurt their legacy it just doesn’t get counted for me.

Album Rating: 4.5

TOCS aged like milk for the most part

TOCS is still incredible I love it a lot, just not as good as the 3 that follow it

Album Rating: 5.0

i mean some songs hit more than others, i still love reinventing, down set go, im content with losing, and the closer more than many later songs tbh

Album Rating: 5.0

TOCS is one of the perfect post-hardcore albums of its time. If that's not your bag though, fair enough. I hated it when it came out.

Album Rating: 5.0

Boy Brushed Red is just bellissimo