Album Rating: 4.9

Opener and closer are best

Album Rating: 5.0

Batter Up has grown on me too. I love the line about the night sky over Camden. I grew up in Philly so the line feels close to home yet it's so eerie because it's an basically about a UFO (I'm assuming that's the right preception?)

It's funny how the tracks I found the most drab and uninteresting at first have become my favorites.

lit me up is 2nd best here considering same logic/teeth exists

Album Rating: 5.0

Same Logic/Teeth is definitely up there. It's like the prototypical Brand New song. But for that same reason, it doesn't hold a candle to the slow burn of Lit Me Up. Song just defies the ceiling of what a bare minimal (mostly just drum beats) song should be able to do.

Album Rating: 5.0

Same Logic is my most returned to song on this album frrshrr. I agree with you too though sowing, it shouldn't be possible for such a minimal song to be so massive

Album Rating: 5.0

Sint knows as usual.

Album Rating: 4.5

batter up is best



don’t think another bn song touches it as far as being an emotional wrecking ball

Album Rating: 5.0

Batter Up is alright ... idk doesn't do as much for me.

Album Rating: 4.9

"Same Logic is my most returned to song on this album frrshrr"

Yes it's top 3 def

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Same Logic was my best song of 2017, a top 5 Brand New song, and one of my favorite songs of all time.



It hasn't even been a year yet.

Album Rating: 5.0

Same Logic and 137 are the best songs on here, particularily 137.

Album Rating: 3.5

"451" has one of the best choruses Brand New has ever written but I think I'd agree with "Lit Me Up" being the best here.

Album Rating: 4.5

feels good to see so many people validating my opinions right now lmao. Same Logic is my favorite here, followed by Lit Me Up, then In The Water. Never understood the hype for Waste, I think it's way too simple and kinda bland musically.

Album Rating: 4.5

12. no control

11. desert

10. out of mana

9. can't get it out

8. could never be heaven

7. waste

6. 451

5. lit me up

4. 137

3. in the water

2. same logic/teeth

1. batter up

Album Rating: 4.5

can't disagree with too much there

Album Rating: 5.0

It's probably time for me to re-think my ranking as well. Here's your official fanboy take:



12. No Control

11. Out of Mana

10. Could Never Be Heaven

9. Waste

8. Desert

7. Can't Get It Out

6. 451

5. 137

4. Same Logic/Teeth

3. In The Water

2. Batter Up

1. Lit Me Up

Album Rating: 4.5

Sowing 💕

Album Rating: 4.5

same top 6, different order, i'll take it. all 6 of those songs are straight 5s so

Album Rating: 4.0

Scream in there!



AAAAAAAAARGH



(seriously though, Waste is cool, 137 and In the Water are the best tho)

Album Rating: 5.0

The "I'm a ghost" outro is by far the best hidden track here. Can you imagine they extended that part out into "Sealed to Me"?