It's sad but true

it's really impressive the way they do stylistically create the elements in the index, i think the issue to me is that water and earth's theme appropriate stylings really don't play to their strengths and so they kinda bore the piss out of me generally

Album Rating: 4.0

Water is amazing, fool

Album Rating: 3.5

I think they pulled off the Alchemy Index amazingly well.

Album Rating: 4.0

i agree. but i do think fire and water worked better than earth and air. air wouldve been the most difficult style to make if they didnt want it to sound like water, because being saturated in guitar effects are heavily needed for both. air didnt work too well, but earth was fine.



after reading the review, i wanna hear what it would sound like if earth was tribal drum based lol

Air sounds like bogstandard indie rock.
Water is by far the best, it's incredible

Album Rating: 4.5

about once a year, Earth (and the last two songs especially) hit me harder than usual

tonight's that once a year

Album Rating: 4.0

Earth is good but Air has some of their best songs

Album Rating: 4.0

I was left pretty underwhelmed by this whenever i jammed but ill give it another go



As someone whos favorite thrice album is 1-2, i was disappointed when i heard this. But i will spin it again soon

Album Rating: 4.0

The first four songs are amazing and the rest veers from good to meh

Album Rating: 4.5

tbh I have this at a 4.5 cause I think the Index as a whole (all 4 EPs) are a 4.5

individually, these 2 would probably be a 4 and I and II would be a 4.5, but it's a "greater than the sum of their parts" thing

Album Rating: 4.0

It's why i was left so underwhelmed by this. Like, 1&2 is my favorite thrice release because it perfectly balances both the heavier and quieter side of the band, and does a fantastic job at emulating fire and water. It got my expectations too high for this one tho

Album Rating: 3.5

Daedalus >>>>>>>

Yeah this pales in comparison to fire and water

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

I speak in many tongues of many men

Argue with angels and I always win

But I don't know the first thing about love.



Top 10 Thrice song for me. Earth is underrated.

Album Rating: 3.5

Daedalus always hits me in the feels, every time.



Earth is underrated, but I have to say that all of the discs are stellar. I'd probably go in order, honestly, Fire > Water > Air > Earth, but I really do love all of them.

Album Rating: 4.0

Water > Fire = Air > Earth

Album Rating: 4.0

acceptable ranking

Water > Air > Fire = Earth

I dunno, Fire is probs a bit better than Earth but they are pretty close for me. Water is pretty much perfect and Air is just right behind it.

Album Rating: 3.0

after first full listen: fire >>> water >= earth



air is too much of a mixed bag to be placed properly in the ranking