Album Rating: 4.5
Have a Cigar and Money both equally rule and have my two favorite Floyd basslines as well, yet both are the weakest song on their respective album
|
| |
Have a Cigar MAY be the weakest on WYWH, though it's almost dumb to pick a worst song on that album, but Money is not the weakest song here.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
"Have a Cigar MAY be the weakest on WYWH, though it's almost dumb to pick a worst song on that album, but Money is not the weakest song here."
"Money" is without a doubt the weakest and "Have a Cigar" is my favorite on WYWH...honestly, I'd be in the minority here, but the t/t is my least favorite on WYWH.
|
| |
Ars... wtf is up with your faves being the worst song on an album and your least faves being the best
|
| |
Nero knows your trick, Ars.
|
| |
I might agree with Ars on WYWH, although that album really has no weak points. We're just splitting hairs here.
|
| |
If I had to pick a least fave on that album, it would be Cigar, and insinuating that the song is in any way flawed just sounds stupid.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
"Ars... wtf is up with your faves being the worst song on an album and your least faves being the best"
I'm just being honest. I like the t/t on WYWH, but it's really not nearly as great as the rest of the album.
"Have a Cigar" has some of Floyd's best lyrics ever, plus that outro is wonderful.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
"Nero knows your trick, Ars."
It's not a trick. I try to ignore's Sputnik's opinion when determining my opinion on an album. If that opinion happens to match up with Sputnik's, then cool.
It often doesn't, oh well.
You know I was talking to a guy in my dorm earlier today about Floyd and his opinions vastly differed from both mine and yours it got me thinking: are you sure you guys aren't letting Sputnik influence your opinions a little too much?
|
| |
Shine On is easily the best on WYWH anyway
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
...
Honestly...
WWYH:
1.Have a Cigar
2.Welcome to the Machine
3.Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX
4.Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
5.Wish You Were Here
...
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
^no way ars. absolutely no way.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
i love you but that ranking is no bueno
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
Yes way. Then again Wish You Were Here isn't even my favorite Floyd.
"i love you but that ranking is no bueno"
It's my personal opinion. Unlike a lot of people on here, I'm not here to push it on anymore,
but I doubt it'll change since i've heard the album so many times.
|
| |
how many times man!?
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
Too many to count. I grew up with this album haha. I grew up with Meddle, Dark Side, and
Animals too.
So when I got into Floyd years later I was like "holy shit I know like all of these songs..."
Plus i've heard them all in full many times since then.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
"money has the best bass line of all time"
it is pretty close but no....
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
"1.Have a Cigar
2.Welcome to the Machine
3.Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts VI-IX
4.Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I-V
5.Wish You Were Here"
Damn my ranking is literally the reverse of this
|
| |
Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts I-V is easily my favourite from WYWH.
Have a Cigar is great though, thanks in no small part to Roy Harper.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
""Money" is without a doubt the weakest and "Have a Cigar" is my favorite on WYWH...honestly, I'd be in the minority here, but the t/t is my least favorite on WYWH."
wow smae
i love the second half of shine on too it's a tough choice but yeah
|
| |
|
|
