Nah I've seen people say MAYH is the best Opeth WAY before I ever even interacted with JT. It's my 3rd favourite anywho.
|
| |
Well it's a not exactly a rare opinion even outside Sputnik so that doesn't surprise me at all. It certainly isn't a result of one user's opinion.
|
| |
Yeah, most people say MAYH is the best followed by BWP.
Even if Watershed was an incoherent mess, each song Is perfectly capable of standing on its own two feet
|
| |
@Choccy: I'd say only 4 of the songs on WS are capable of that. I don't like the other 3 much at all, either within the context of
the album or on their own.
|
| |
The only problem I have with Watershed is that as a whole, it doesn't feel like a single piece of work at all. That doesn't really phase me anymore though. Based on those 4 songs alone, I'd say it deserves a 4 as the bare minimum, JT
|
| |
Nah I definitely don't like it as much as this and considering how incohesive and inconsistent it (WS) is I can't give it any higher than a 3.5.
|
| |
Surprised you didn't immediately like PC given how much you enjoy this
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
Where's the Still Life love
SL > MAYH
|
| |
Pleb, Green and Talons all think SL is their best I think
|
| |
SL is 4th best.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
Second for me.
|
| |
the last three songs from Pale Communion :3. Amazing.
|
| |
Faith in Others is overrated. I mean, after SW said it was the most beautiful thing that Mikael's ever written, I was expecting something much more than what I got. Coil and Isolation Years are more emotional
|
| |
"Coil and Isolation Years are more emotional"
Out of all the songs u could have chosen, you chose them two? Really?! Good songs but come on now.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.2 | Sound Off
BWP is my favorite not SL, though it's certainly close. SL and mayh might be tied for second best for me
|
| |
Well both of those songs are definitely more emotional and beautiful than Faith In Others
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
Isolation Years is gorg
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.2 | Sound Off
Yeah I get more emotion from those than Faith in Others tbh especially Isolation Years
|
| |
Pretty underrated too. Most reviews I've read on this site don't like it and say GC should have been the closer
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.2 | Sound Off
Ugh noooo
|
| |
|
|
