Album Rating: 2.5

Have you forgotten abou "the black album"?

Album Rating: 1.0

it is better than load or reload but i just dont like it as much as the other albums



1.5/5

Album Rating: 4.5

Have you forgotten abou "the black album"?

Album Rating: 2.5

i actually think this is an ok album, the guitar riffs and awesome drumming really are catchy, the lyrics are quite good to. unfortunately the lack of guitar solos and poor production really bring this album down.

Saying that though it's still better than 95% of mainstream music today

Album Rating: 4.5

yeah, i liked this album, nowhere near as much as ride the lightning or the black album but it beats any slipknot or static x album.

The album is good compared to other music coming out these days, but horrible compared to old metallica. It's good, just not Metallica good. The only plus to the album in my view, is the dvd. Like I said, the music isn't that great, but you still get to watch Metallica play.

Album Rating: 3.0

Meh, I think this album is pretty good. Its one of only 2 Metallica albums I listen to regularly.

Album Rating: 3.0

is metallica's worst album?? the guitar is sh**e the drums are alright this album is not the metallica quallity that i seen in "ride the lighting" and "the black album"





2/5

Album Rating: 3.5

i agree, but this better than alot of metal around now.

Album Rating: 3.0

i was dissapointed.but it was still a kickass album



in my opinion ride the lightning was the worst

the only good songs are like

ride the lightning,

fight fire with fire

and fade to black



in my opinion

Album Rating: 2.5

I disagree, Call Of The Ktulu and For Whom The Bell Tolls are excellent tracks aswell, but thats just my opinion

Album Rating: 4.0

Ride the Lightning wasn't their worst, but in my opinion it was no where near their best.

agree with metallicaman that bells, ktulu are great tracks

Album Rating: 3.0

fuck yeah they are.

slipped my mind.

ride the lightning is one of my favorite songs....mainly cuz the solo, AWSOM!...

also im not gunna be one of those people who say stuff lyk "st. anger is there worst album (even though it may be the truth)" but i think this album is cool... if u get past the production sound, or lars's trash can drumming... its pretty good......nuthin against lars.. he does some amazing drumming on this album...

hey did anyone hear about metallica making a new album???
maybe they will make a comeback, lyk return to there old sound as in ride the lightning or master of puppets...maybe, or at least put some solos in the songs

Album Rating: 3.5

their new album comes out this late this year or early next year (thats what ive heard).

also ride the lightning is one of metallicas greatest albums, that master of puppets and the black album are my favourite 'tallica albums.

their worst album is Load.This Message Edited On 05.13.06

Album Rating: 3.0

No, I think St Anger is their worst, even though It's one of my favourite. Load and ReLoad are deeply misunderstood albums, which have some ripping tracks. IMO of course. And how can RtL be anyone's least favourite? Pearler of a record, that one.

Album Rating: 3.5

my opinion mate

Album Rating: 3.0

Which one is always entitled to. That's the beauty of such a forum - a complete collaboration of ideas and beliefs clashing together to further people's interest in a topic and to foster a relationship between individuals who share similar (or different) opinions and ideas.

Mate. :thumb:

Album Rating: 3.5

good to know i have a friend here This Message Edited On 05.14.06

I agree that Load and Reload are much maligned, somewhat unjustly, and that they have some ripping tracks, but I think their faults lie in their inconsistency. There was a rather high level of filler, I felt.
As for RtL, Metallica have never made a bad album. Even St. Anger is just deeply, deeply average. But, like, REALLY deeply.