Lady Gaga Born This Way
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
qwe3
August 12th 2011


21836 Comments


how do you measure genuineness

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


Americano just reeks of ingenuity and a lack of commitment to her fans compared to say, Poker Face or Alejandro

hell, just listen to that faux-latin flavour compared to the tortured genius of Bad Romance. how the mighty have fallen

Tyrael
August 12th 2011


21108 Comments


Plow you're a hero

never change

conradtao
Emeritus
August 12th 2011


2090 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

No, Meatplow makes a good point for the album. I mean, if that's how you view it and that's what you hear, then of course you're bound to enjoy the record - and it's useless to "try changing his mind" since that's a pretty solid way to look at the album. I just.. disagree, I suppose. To me, this stuff reeks of overproduction (and I disagree with you, plow, about the "finest sound engineering" - a lot of this stuff sounds messy and cheap, which may be intentional but it still sounds kinda..bad).

robertsona
Emeritus
August 12th 2011


28660 Comments


shut the fuck up andcas jesus CHRIST shut UP god you could be arguing with a neonazi and id still want to agree with him

Tyrael
August 12th 2011


21108 Comments


shut the fuck up andcas jesus CHRIST shut UP god you could be arguing with a neonazi and id still want to agree with him

Dude you just turned exaggerating into a form of art


Parallels
August 12th 2011


10215 Comments


Hey, what'd I miss?

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


I just.. disagree, I suppose. To me, this stuff reeks of overproduction (and I disagree with you, plow, about the "finest sound engineering" - a lot of this stuff sounds messy and cheap, which may be intentional but it still sounds kinda..bad).


a lot of it is personal taste, I can see why people find this downright obnoxious to listen to.

just when people talk at length about Gaga whether they love her or hate her it's always painful, it's a unique phenomenon I want to probe to uncover a kind of post-modern truth

what is the essence

robertsona
Emeritus
August 12th 2011


28660 Comments


for the record: andcas deleted/edited his post from something like "well i guess i wont argue with a lady gaga fan cuz they just worship her without thinking like meatplow over here" to whatever bullshit it is now and pretended he never posted it which is very mature and all of course but i'm not editing mine because andcas is still an insufferable moron

robertsona
Emeritus
August 12th 2011


28660 Comments


u should say something stupid and then edit it, that seems like a fair way to carry on a conversation

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


it's cool that you love this album meat. we share different opinions and I respect yours so agree to disagree.


well, this is a website centered around music opinions. if everybody agreed to disagree there would be no debate and hence, little discussion

I respect your opinion and that of everyone else's here too, but I have questionable music tastes at times and it's always a good mental workout trying to defend the integrity of the music I claim to hold so dearly

gaslightanthem
August 12th 2011


5208 Comments


i agree with alex


andcas you're insufferable

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


for the record: andcas deleted/edited his post from something like "well i guess i wont argue
with a lady gaga fan cuz they just worship her without thinking like meatplow over here" to whatever
bullshit it is now and pretended he never posted it which is very mature and all of course but i'm
not editing mine because andcas is still an insufferable moron


eh, i've made edits like this sometimes after reading over and regretting what i've posted cause I
misunderstood something

I wouldn't consider myself a fan of Gaga or any pop divas as such, I tend to dislike her whorish
image and don't care for anything she talks about or stands for. Critics tend to say this side of
her overshadows the music and disguises its superficiality, and in reality it does. Still, for the
most part I get off on the production and feel there are plenty of tightly written pop hooks to keep
me satisfied, even though what defines quality in this manner seems to be highly arguable from
person to person.

I really do think Born This Way gets a bad rap on sputnik, and for better or worse is one of
the defining pop albums of the current era . i'd rather be seeing the video for Judas or
The Edge of Glory on music video stations for the 100th time than Ke$ha or Nicki Minaj's
weird face

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


Clarence Clemon's Saxophone Solo

Meatplow loses his shit

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


people said the same thing about the bugle in PJ Harvey's This Glorious Land

and that song is wayyyyyyyy better than The Edge of Glory

Parallels
August 12th 2011


10215 Comments


and The Fame is wayyyyy better than this.

Edit: lol plow you 5'd it. hahah that's awesome.

Meatplow
August 12th 2011


5523 Comments


nah

don't think I could stomach her little monsters

lol plow you 5'd it. hahah that's awesome.


my guilty pleasure of 2010

gaslightanthem
August 12th 2011


5208 Comments


do you feel persecuted andcas

Tyrael
August 12th 2011


21108 Comments


Gaga has such an impressive voice, she blew me away when I went to see her live

gaslightanthem
August 13th 2011


5208 Comments


i'm not sure what you're talking about
maybe i've missed something
does the hypocrisy of your post strike you at all



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy