Album Rating: 3.5

he's been going through a bunch of personal stuff that probably impacted the quality of his work. of course his haters jumped on the opportunity to publicize his divorce and openly share the public documents amongst themselves.

"eh, he's a quality, honest reviewer with solid, well-founded takes and a good sense of humor. "

ever since the fader article and the robert christgau comments he's been everything but honest, he also becomes less funnier with each passing day

Album Rating: 5.0

what the fks this whole divorced shit i keep reading this but seen nothing solid? so what hes having a divorce and people are piling on him??

keep in mind a whole lotta people absolutely despise him especially everyone on /mu/

@cormano so what did he do

Album Rating: 5.0

@jay



[2]



I don’t know anyone irl that takes his opinions as fact but I know multiple people who hate on him because they think that

Album Rating: 5.0

I say I hate him but I watch any review he does of stuff I might like.

I just hate his tic toc shit. Man's 36 ffs

Tik tok gets so much traction tho it’s almost a mistake to not do it

he's pretty allright on twitch, way more earnest and engaging for sure, except for that Adrianne Lenker interview where he cries

@jester
deleted his meme account after the fader said he appealed to the alt right crowd and he's been pretty much doing dmg control ever since. christgau took notice that rarely, if ever, any female artists ever cracked his tops, which at that point was true, that's why his placing of the charlixcx and jessie ware records as aoty after this controversy came off as very disingenuous, at least to me, same with lingua ignota and little simz shortly after

Album Rating: 4.0

I mean that also just sounds like he's listening to more women musicians.

“ Tik tok gets so much traction tho it’s almost a mistake to not do it”
Pretty much.
I think there’s a lot of tall poppy syndrome, I mean he’s just one guy. Calm the f down lol

I never said he didn't listen to them or covered them to some extent, he sure did and he shit on a lot of those records until a more credible and well established music critic pointed it out lol and even if what you implied were true he still only acted cause his reputation was at stake

Album Rating: 3.5

I mean that Jessie Ware album fucking bops so it being his AOTY isn’t that farfetched

Album Rating: 4.5

'deleted his meme account after the fader said he appealed to the alt right crowd'



i remember that meme account and it didnt do that in the slightest. it was just absurd meme humour. if it did appeal to the alt right that was entirely accidental/coincidental. that fader article was truly ridiculous

Album Rating: 3.0

it was insidious, actually... fuckers actively trying to dirty someone's name. He should've sued, tbh. Too much of a beta cuck soyboy NPC, ig.

“I never said he didn't listen to them or covered them to some extent, he sure did and he shit on a lot of those records until a more credible and well established music critic pointed it out lol and even if what you implied were true he still only acted cause his reputation was at stake”

This is so dumb lol

Album Rating: 5.0

"ever since the fader article and the robert christgau comments he's been everything but honest" lol just searched up both and i have no words for you

Album Rating: 5.0

as an aside, you have excellent 5s @cormano

“and even if what you implied were true he still only acted cause his reputation was at stake”

You know this, how? The idea that Fantano’s reputation was at stake because of a few random comments about his year end lists is just absurd. The guy has a pretty hardcore following. I don’t even like his content but that’s just blatantly nonsense and most likely just wishful thinking on your part.

Album Rating: 4.5

When did this thread turn into RYM tf