Unpopular opinion? Get your pitchforks laddies!

Album Rating: 3.0

genuinely surprised this is still at 4.1

Fivehundred and twenty-first time poster here. I really enjoyed this the first couple of spins and there are a some memorable moments/tracks but the majority of the songs just aren't that great, especially compared to TGG.

Album Rating: 4.0

I never really enjoyed the whole record, but Cardinals is definitely one of my favorite TWY songs.

Album Rating: 4.0

I haven't seen much discussion in this thread about "I Don't Like Who I Was Then". That song is this albums version of "Don't Let Me Cave In" from Suburbia and "Teenage Parents" for TGG -- a fast-paced straight up pop-punk jam with a huge chorus that will go down as the go-to track from this album. Just classic Wonder Years.

Album Rating: 4.0

I agree, it's my 2nd favourite song here after cigs & saints

^yea gotta agree with that one.

also i think it needs to be said that the title track is really great, contrary to TWY's previous little acoustic numbers

Album Rating: 4.4

title track is terrific agreed

omg saw wonder and thought stevie was on the front page hope restored in sput oh wait

Lol sucks for you

Damn this is nowhere as good as TGG

Album Rating: 2.5

I concur.

Album Rating: 2.5

Boooooooooring

Album Rating: 4.0

Still a 4.5 tho?

"Wow, this was disappointing. Lemme just drop this near classic rating on it to express my disgust."

Album Rating: 2.5

Well, it COULD be a 4.3... or something.

It's hard to explain, I think the actual musicianship is fantastic all around but I feel there's some disconnect between me and the songs unlike The Greatest Generation which I felt very close to. Maybe I just need to give a few more listens

"9/10. Fuck this is disappointing. Nowhere near as good as their previous album."

9/10 seems pretty close to 10/10 from where I'm standing.

Well I was over exaggerating when I said this is no where as good

Album Rating: 2.0

This is probably more formulaic than TGG wtf how do people like this band so much