Album Rating: 3.0

Got 'em!

man, not even misconduct allegations could get em. at least the other brother is now doing throwback stuff

Album Rating: 2.8 | Sound Off

ayeah good rev Sunsun

These guys and God Is an Astronaut got a lot of people into post rock in the 00s IMO. Later, they kind of got lost amid better bands. GIAA had a good comeback with heavier stuff tho.

Some wild takes in here with "band was never good" mentality. The Earth is Not a Cold Dead Place is a phenomenal record, and should be up there with one of the most classic/influential post-rock records of all time. I got pretty burnt out on post-rock over the years but this band is pretty legendary in my eyes.

Album Rating: 2.5

Yeah, I get that the band has always had its detractors but Earth remains about as good as their sort of thing can get.

Earth is flaccid music for bunk indie flick directors and letting it keep any pedestal is an insult to post rock (RIP)'s memory

trouble with post-rock is that i would like to honour its memory, but there is a severe limitation on its memorability

band is the hindenburg of music

this is the worst explosion in the sky that ever happened in september

definitely their worst record of the day

Earth Is Not is like a collection of jingles written for drug commercials that spend two minutes spelling out the side effects for you

Post rock is a genre of yesteryear at this point

soon we gonna need a post post rock

Peaked with Godspeed anyways

*bark psychosis

bark psychosis and talk talk [2]

bark psychosis [3]

This band was amazing before I discovered better Post Rock bands.

I have never liked this band