are these guys still metalcore?

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

Sadly, among the three reviews we already have, this one speaks the biggest amount of truth. The beast that is Nickelback lives on.

Nickelback, spearheaded by Chad Kroeger, isn't selling out to stay "savvy" with today's music.

Nickelback 'selling out'? I'm having a hard time imagining what that would sound like

Album Rating: 1.5

There are many things in this review that make me believe it's not a serious one. Besides, it's too well-written for a Nickelback fan. Pos.

Finally! Someone who writes an ACTUAL REVIEW of the cd and does not rant about the band! I also loved the record, man! Gotta love Kroeger's voice!

yeah such an awesome voice lolol

not really relevant i guess but can we please talk about how "Photograph" is the worst thing ever?

It really, really is.

Photograph rules. It's too entertaining to be bad.

Album Rating: 4.5

a positive review for a nickelback album on this site im surprised, but at the same time i completely agree with this review. many reviews get too emotional when discussing nickelback and not enough emphasis on any positive aspects, if any at all. good review.

a standout work for 2011

it's fitting that you start your review with a cliche

huh I never thought these guys were that good but maybe I'll check this out

I know this is a typical Nickelback album, but you could have gotten that point across without using the word "typical" so many times.

Album Rating: 4.5

Thanks to the people who liked the review! not a troll, but i think a good album deserves some good credit. I think someone has to give credit to a band that does the job, love them or hate them

Album Rating: 1.5

However much I don't enjoy the band, it has to be admitted that they do whatever they do well-even if what they do may not be the greatest thing in the world, theres hundreds of millions of Nickelback fans out there-they've perfected their formula and they're gonna stick by their guns it seems, no matter what.



By the way, most of the negs are probably just because you gave a Nickelback album a positive review. The review was actually pretty well written (especially in comparison to that one positive Dark Horse review where the guy talked about how he enjoyed "Something In Your Mouth" because he was horny. It was a bit weird.)

Wow, some of you really need to grow up. Listen to the album before you judge it. I just finished listening to it, and it's really good. I swear, most of you probably just hate Nickelback solely because they're mainstream.

How Nickelback can garner this kind of fame while geniuses like Clutch (also considered 'hard rock') are next to unknown escapes me.

Album Rating: 1.0

Just so you know, its impossible for nickelback to sell out to stay with todays savvy music. Its impossible to sell out because there was never any quality to their work

most people that rated this though probably haven't heard it. I mean i'm sure it's a 1 because all their albums have been so far but I'm not going to rate this until I hear it (which is hopefully never). (in response to tikilamb/andcas)

lolol andcas always right on time with the perfect youtube clips