Catamenia Eternal Winter's Prophecy
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Acanthus
August 14th 2011


9812 Comments


Thanks Metalstyles, I'll check those out later on today then!

pizzamachine
August 14th 2011


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

but that doesn't make it a universal compliment.



That's why I said it was considered a compliment of sorts (meaning sort of), but I can see what you're getting at. I hate it when I do lofty statements. :/



That whole portion is basically saying "this album is perfect, and if you don't agree you are wrong"



Yes hahaha I couldn't think of any other way to put it so that it was less ridiculous. I basically couldn't find any negatives about the album.



Also you use the word "melodic" 6 times in 8 sentences in that middle paragraph.



Yup. :/



Thanks for the critique!

Sowing
Moderator
August 14th 2011


43962 Comments


That's why I said it was considered a compliment of sorts

But the way you wrote it makes it seem like the word's connotation has changed over the years, which isn't really true.

And if the album is perfect, then why is it a 4? Surely it isn't flawless.

And as far as using the same words go, it happens. Just seems like something you normally would have picked up on with even a casual proofread.

Anyway, not trying to be a dick or anything. Like I said you are a good reviewer, this is just one out of a hundred and however many that I simply can't get behind

pizzamachine
August 14th 2011


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

which isn't really true.



Oh.





And if the album is perfect, then why is it a 4? Surely it isn't flawless.



Even though it's extremely solid, there are definitely better albums out there. Stormlord - The Gorgon Cult, for example. Often as a reviewer I need to see how an album compares to other albums in the genre. The context is important for me to make a decision.



"Just seems like something you normally would have picked up on with even a casual proofread."



I did! I just couldn't get rid of them. :/





Don't worry, I don't think you're a dick. : )

Sowing
Moderator
August 14th 2011


43962 Comments


I understand that this may not be your definition of a 5, and that there are better albums out there, but saying things like "If anyone was to complain about this album, their complaints would bounce off as merit-less" doesn't defend the rating you gave it at all. It doesn't really say anything besides that you are closed off to the idea of this album possessing flaws. And if you saw the redundancy why didn't you edit it? Were you going for a joking/anything flies tone to the extent that it was worth sacrificing readability? I dunno I'm just lost, I don't get what your thought process was when you decided to write this review.

With that said, the opening paragraph is pretty awesome. I especially like the part about donning viking attire and laying waste to villages...although unfortunately that is the portion that has a lot less to do with the music : /

pizzamachine
August 14th 2011


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

doesn't defend the rating you gave it at all. It doesn't really say anything besides that you are closed off to the idea of this album possessing flaws.



Yes, that's exactly what I was doing. I was trying to put some closure on what I thought about the album.



Were you going for a joking/anything flies tone to the extent that it was worth sacrificing readability? I dunno I'm just lost, I don't get what your thought process was when you decided to write this review.



TOO FAR



With that said, the opening paragraph is pretty awesome.



Thanks!





Tyrael
August 14th 2011


21108 Comments


So, what's the relation between vikings and BM? Except for the fact that they're both from scandinavia ofc

Sowing
Moderator
August 14th 2011


43962 Comments


What? I can't even follow your logic pizza, and it's hard to tell if you are joking or not so im just gunna stop lol.

Metalstyles
August 14th 2011


8576 Comments


@Tyraelxy
These guys have wolves on their album covers, vikings probably had them as pets.

pizzamachine
August 14th 2011


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

@ Sowing: Hard to compete with a pizza ain't it? The tasty meat, the delicious sauce, the succulent spices.



@ Metal: lol never would have thought of that

Metalstyles
August 14th 2011


8576 Comments


Well he asked a proper question I had to say SOMETHING

pizzamachine
August 14th 2011


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Hey, it's a legit answer methinks.

pizzamachine
August 31st 2023


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Slaps

Hyperion1001
Emeritus
August 31st 2023


26069 Comments


this one and morning crimson are probably my two favorites. kingdom of legions is so good.

Hyperion1001
Emeritus
September 24th 2023


26069 Comments


melodies of trvth

band is severely underrated.

pizzamachine
September 24th 2023


27267 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Trvly



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy