Album Rating: 3.5

Do you mean by "American Water" a band or a song cuz i wanna check it ?

Silver Jews - American Water



back to Bad Books!

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

offense untaken



listened to this again last night in the car and still relatively unimpressed, might lower my rating WE'LL SEE

dammit eric you beat me to it (even though I've had this for weeks and haven't attempted to start writing)

pretty much agree though

yeah you two, I saw you rated this similarly and it kinda solidified my opinion, admittedly.

and thanks for the negs, all you Sea-fans out there!

Album Rating: 3.5

I find theme very authentic

huh? the negs? the band?

i really enjoyed this album and think it probably deserves a bit of a higher rating, however u have some good points in there.
awesome job sea.

as disappointing as this is, I Begged You Everything is one of the best songs Hull has written

i only just heard about this. highlights just how disappointing it is.

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

yes Mikey, I Begged You Everything is fantastic

just gave this another try and really enjoyed it. i like this a lot more than any of kevin's solo albums.

Album Rating: 3.0

Kev Dev boosted this album with "You're a Mirror..." fantastic song, faint reminiscence of Elliot Smith. Album does have its unfortunate disappointments though.

Album Rating: 4.0

This is loads better than I anticipated it was gonna be. I'm not fully understanding why this isn't getting more love.

If I’m loving Manchester Orchestra, are these guys worth checking out? I’ve listened to a few tracks on Spotify and they sound solid. Ratings for both albums seem pretty subpar though.