I thought this was a fantastic review. I haven't heard the album, don't plan to either. I think most
of the negative comments (I'm looking at your Strikey) were reactions to a disagreement in rating. I
mean, it's a really good review. I think so anyway.
|
| |
Album Rating: 1.0
And cheers for the pos's guys. I'm gonna agree with Aids that the negs are down to people disagreeing with the rating rather than the review itself but I suppose it comes with the territory when you give something a low rating, people will be more easily moved to disagree and want to express that, fair enough.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
I agree with Knott; too much focus on the lyrics. While I can see your point, punk-poppers don't grow up so quickly. They always have a bit of adolescence. Also, I like that they took their wit and matched it with a modern theme. Best album from them by far since The Green Album.
|
| |
This is surprisingly not horrible, but it's nowhere near a return to form.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off
lol Lakes. Review is decent, take a pos
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off
What a load of bollocks. I do disagree with the rating, but I have no inclination towards this band whatsoever. Pinkerton and Blue are good... I don't adore either of them. And this album is a 4, in my head, but I don't judge reviews based on that.
I also didn't neg this. I think there's a tone of arrogance running through it; I think you don't talk anywhere nearly enough about the music; but I didn't neg it. It takes something pretty bad for me to vote against a review. So... shut the fuck up.
|
| |
I've only heard "Memories" from this and I think it sucks. I agree with your first paragraph: if the Blue album and Pinkerton never existed, would we still be talking about Weezer so much? Would people like the music they're making now as much? Interesting to think about.
|
| |
I really see how this review is arrogant. I mean, he gave it a 1 and in my opinion justified that ranking. I guess it's a bit cynical, but that comes with the territory when discussing Weezer these days.
|
| |
anyone who doesnt like ruling me doesnt like fun
memories is ok
trainwrecks rules
the rest are varying levels of eh-good
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off
I'd say it's better than Raditude and maybe Red, but nothing else.
|
| |
123 Slum.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off
People really exaggerate how bad Make Believe was.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off
I dunno I have a soft spot for quite a few songs on there that are much better than half or more of the songs on here.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off
What do you think are the weaker tracks?
|
| |
Very well-written. Good job.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
this CD owns hard, sorry. posing because it's well-written, but I surely fundamentally disagree with you here. "Run Away" is such a good fucking song.
SOMETIMES I WISH I WERE A HOUSE AT THE END OF YOUR BLOCK
|
| |
Generic Weezer album.
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
I think Trainwrecks might be my favorite.
|
| |
So... shut the fuck up.
Adam, chill. I wasn't saying you negged it or anything I just thought it was strange that you disliked the review because I read it and thought it was great (I rarely pos, but did here). I just made a guess that you didn't like the review because the rating was so low, I was trying to start a sputnik flame war.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off
Well, I didn't like the review, haha. But I didn't neg. I neg so so rarely. But it was mostly the implication that I would've negged it because I liked the album which annoyed me.
Any case that was targeted half at both of you so I retract half of it, and probably the other half too. Sowwy!
|
| |
|
|
