Michael Giacchino Lost: Season 5
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
DaveyBoy
Emeritus
May 13th 2010


22500 Comments


Ta. I saw all that except for the washing up on the beach & taking into the caves thing.

Was there not a sequence involving Jack & Kate stumbling onto the skeletons at all OR did they just appear at the end of the episode?

Acre
May 13th 2010


847 Comments


The clothes aren't necessarily a continuity error. Jack says it would take "at least" 50 years for the clothes to deteriorate; he doesn't have any sort of specific way of knowing when the skeletons come from time wise, as he unfortunately left his paleontology tools at home.

And the sequence with Jack and Kate was just a flashback/forward reminding the viewer of that scene's occurance in Season 1. Otherwise, the rest of the episode took place in the Jacob/MIB past.

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


Davey, they found the skeletons in season 1.

DaveyBoy
Emeritus
May 13th 2010


22500 Comments


"Davey, they found the skeletons in season 1."

F**k, I can hardly remember what I had for dinner 2 days ago!

Waior
May 13th 2010


11778 Comments


This is the perfect review for us to on-topic-ly discuss Lost without leaving the review site. Brilliant.

DaveyBoy
Emeritus
May 13th 2010


22500 Comments


So whose dream is it gonna be? ;-)

TheSpirit
Emeritus
May 13th 2010


30304 Comments


I was watching the episode that other day where those aliens reincarnated Napolean, and the church freaked out because they thought he was the Antichrist. Probably my favorite episode of the series.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
May 13th 2010


32289 Comments


This is the perfect review for us to on-topic-ly discuss Lost without leaving the review site. Brilliant.

And here's hoping that people wanting to avoid spoilers will probably assume we're discussing this too
The clothes aren't necessarily a continuity error. Jack says it would take "at least" 50 years for the clothes to deteriorate; he doesn't have any sort of specific way of knowing when the skeletons come from time wise, as he unfortunately left his paleontology tools at home.

Regardless of how knowlegable Jack may have been on the subject or not, its still a continuity error

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


I was subscribing to the theory that Jacob and MIB are the same person prior to last night. Never once suspected that they were brothers.

thatoneguy726
May 13th 2010


1669 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Haha, Satellite, do you by chance listen to Jay and Jack?

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
May 13th 2010


32289 Comments


I'm digging the fact that MIB's soul is the smoke monster,and not just him as a whole. I initially thought that maybe MIB was dead for good, and Smokey had just assumed his body, but that wouldn't work given the "fate worse than death" remarks, and Jacob still recognizing smokey as his brother and vice versa

Waior
May 13th 2010


11778 Comments


I'm digging the fact that MIB's soul is the smoke monster


aw what the hell, i haven't seen anything past season four

i am so dumb sometimes

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
May 13th 2010


32289 Comments


And here's hoping that people wanting to avoid spoilers will probably assume we're discussing this too


Geez Waior

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


I'm digging the fact that MIB's soul is the smoke monster, and not just him as a whole.

This. It's become increasingly evident that the smoke monster is 100% evil incarnate over the past two episodes. He was sort of in a gray area for most of the season.

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


Haha, Satellite, do you by chance listen to Jay and Jack?

No. What is that?

thatoneguy726
May 13th 2010


1669 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

A podcast about LOST. I just wondered because they also used the word "preggers" when recapping the episode and it's a running joke that the host Jack is so set on his theory that Jacob and MIB are one and the same... no matter what happens on the show.

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


Haha. Yeah, it was a pretty popular theory. I'll have to check that podcast out.

fr33convict
May 13th 2010


11723 Comments


Jacob's brother had a shitty life. Just saying.

Satellite
May 13th 2010


26539 Comments


Jacob didn't have it much better, really.

fr33convict
May 13th 2010


11723 Comments


Still. He ran away from his murderer/crazy mom and tried to leave the island. Crazy mom then kills everyone he lived with and destroys his plan to leave. He kills his mom out of anger and then Jacob kills him. I think he got the shortest straw.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy