» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
DownPaymentBlues78
October 21st 2005


278 Comments


Then you dont need the greatest hits

innerdark
October 21st 2005


749 Comments


why a record company would re-release some of the worst songs of all time is beyond me...

DownPaymentBlues78
October 21st 2005


278 Comments


What the fuck? Talk about bad music taste. These are all very good songs, but they couldve really included more AFD and some more fan favorites.

innerdark
October 21st 2005


749 Comments


80's
hair
metal
sucks
in
many
ways
shapes
an
forms

DownPaymentBlues78
October 21st 2005


278 Comments


Yes, THAT'S what GNR is, hair metal.

Smooth, hoppus.

innerdark
October 21st 2005


749 Comments


therefore
G'n'Rl
suck
in
many
ways
shapes
an
forms



Storm In A Teacup
October 22nd 2005


47106 Comments


GNR is defaintly not hair metal since I despise those bands and I like GNR.

DownPaymentBlues78
October 22nd 2005


278 Comments


Kripes is right they arent hair metal.

innerdark
October 22nd 2005


749 Comments


they still suck though, mind you i like 1 or 2 or their songs

welcome to the jungle
and
sweet child o' mine

bass_player10
October 22nd 2005


8 Comments


if GnR is hair metal, their definitly alot more hard rock than alot of those bands. alot of hair metal is ljust pop metal and GnR definitly isnt.

anyways alright review... sorta seems like you didnt know what you were talking about though
matt sorum was the drummer on some if not all of use your illusion and all of the spaghetti incident, and gilby clark was the rhythm for aint it fun and since i dont have you so the lineup was kind of wrong. And everyone saying that these are the worst songs, you jsut piss me the fuck off because most hit songs are for a reason. Ive heard Welcome to jungle a million times on radio, CD, GTA watever. just because its mainstream doesnt make it rock any less, same with every other gnr song. btw yesterdays is a kick ass song, so just fuck off

DownPaymentBlues78
October 22nd 2005


278 Comments


No, that is a fact. Each member of GNR is much more talented at their instrument or vocals than any member of blink 182 or green day. Slash owns both... armstrong (?) and is it tom something?

They cant even dream to play like him. Also, Axl has much more range to his voice and can hit notes that those other guys cant come close to. And green day and blink 182 aint exactly got the best bassists around, either...

bass_player10
October 23rd 2005


8 Comments


haha perfect way of putting it. best riff ive heard from blink is stay together for the kids, most of the other stuff is 3 string power chords. shitloads and shitloads of power chords....

mike dirnt is actually a pretty good bassist though...

kingofz
November 3rd 2005


7 Comments


Yeah i would agree that GnR are much more talented at their instruments but does it realy matter who is better at what? If people like their music theyv done a good job. And mike dirnt owns duff on bass

CushMG15
November 3rd 2005


1810 Comments


Why is it that green day seems to be coming up all the time in these forums?

Anyway, Civil War owns me . It's my favorite GnR song. A close second is November Rain.

And Slash (take it easy here, everyone), but does anyone else think he's a smidgen (no sarcasm) overrated?This Message Edited On 11.03.05

ak_theman11
November 4th 2005


19 Comments


No. He is not over-rated.

CushMG15
November 4th 2005


1810 Comments


I'm gonna agree with you on his technicality, but he does seem rather sloppy, at times. Granted I haven't listened to their live cd in quite some time, I recall is playing being quite sloppy on that.

I dunno, maybe I've heard to too many "musically retarded" people in my past that think he's the best guitarist ever...This Message Edited On 11.03.05

Knoxvillelives
November 4th 2005


342 Comments


Okay band, only songs I like are Welcome o the Jungle, Civil War and maybe Paradise City and Sweet Child Of Mine.
Slash is clearer one of the greater guitarrists, but the band just annoyme for the most part.

bass_player10
November 7th 2005


8 Comments


Mike Dirnt owns Duff McKagan??? have u even haerd the bass intro to sweet child o mine? obviously not. go listen to it asshole, then get back to me

Shuffle It All
November 7th 2005


121 Comments


duff is quite a lot better than dirnt, thiough dirnmt is a very good bassist.

slash is over rated in some ways, but also under rated, he is a great shredder and is very fast, but also is extremely melodic and bluesy, personally he's one of the greastest guitarists ever.

shit album really, not there greatest hits, and sympathy for the devil should never have been done.

also, i dont agree with you about izzy, he wrote more than half of all the gnr songs, and whats the onjly album they realeased after he left? a cover album, so that really proves the fact.


Aakon_Keetreh
November 10th 2005


448 Comments


cant go wrong with this cd



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy