Album Rating: 3.5

I don't think any song on here other than the instrumental deserve less than a 2.5 or even a 3. And the way you keep using lyrics as a reason for a song being bad makes it seem like your unfamiliar with Oasis. Oasis have never been about lyrics, there a rock n' roll band. Live Forever's lyrics are pretty cliched' but it's still a great tune.



And you gave She Is Love a 1/5 that song literally sounds like Noel found an unreleased Beatles song and kept it for his own.

Album Rating: 3.5

This is album, is probably the most inconsistent album I own, but it has some of my favourite songs. I don't know wat the fuss about the hindu times is, and i don't think it's that good. Force of nature would've been good with Liam singing the verse, like in Acquiesce. Stop Crying Your Heart Out is a great song, but gets boring at the end, cos nothing happens. Songbird is one of the most beautiful songs i've ever hear. Little by Little is overated. A quick peep and Probably all in my mind are fillers. She is love is incredibly underated. Born on a different cloud is a bit boring. Better man is awesome, and there is a secret track at the 35 minute mark i think.

I don't think any song on here other than the instrumental deserve less than a 2.5 or even a 3. And the way you keep using lyrics as a reason for a song being bad makes it seem like your unfamiliar with Oasis. Oasis have never been about lyrics, there a rock n' roll band. Live Forever's lyrics are pretty cliched' but it's still a great tune.

Album Rating: 3.5

I reckon that although their lyrics probably didn't mean anything when they wrote them, they seem kind of meaningful without meaning anything, if that makes sense. In this album, some songs have lyrics like a story, with a definite meaning, and their lyrics aren't as good as they were when they didn't mean anything.

SOTSOG and HC dont have enough good songs each, so they should be combined to make a much better album "Standing on the shoulder of heathens" lol

what about "Definately standing on the morning glory"?

Album Rating: 2.0

Standing On The Shoulder of Giants > Heathen Chemistry and all other Oasis albums, except MAYBE Definitely Maybe. Discuss (Yes I'm serious with this.)



EDIT: Little By Little, Stop Crying Your Heart Out and She Is Love are excellent songs though.This Message Edited On 08.22.06

The one time i agree with pitchfork is "if you want oasis greatest hits, theyre called definately maybe and whats the story morning glory". What about masterplan

The Hindu Times = best song George Harrison never wrote.

Album Rating: 5.0

personally i really like this album..oh well

Album Rating: 3.5

I'd give this album 3.5 cos singles are impressive. But you have given review as if it is not even worth listening and that's not fair. I disagree with you because I think that it's a good album.

Album Rating: 5.0

1,5/5 are you an idiot!

Album Rating: 2.0

Their worst album imo. A few good songs but a lot of poor ones too, 'The Hindu Times' is clearly the best of the lot though imo

Album Rating: 5.0

1,5? Are you kidding me? 1,5 in rating!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This album is more than good.

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah this is my least favourite of all their albums, but the singles are still very good songs.

Album Rating: 4.0

In fact I'd say the opening 6 are great, then the rest are just very dull and boring.

Album Rating: 2.5

Noel Gallagher always says that "Be here now" is the worst thing that oasis ever made. Bullshit

I just gave 2,5 because Songbird, Little by little, The Hindu Times and SCYHO are pleasant. Well, very pleasant songs.



But Noel's lyrics, instrumentals and Liam's vocals are awful here compared with others albums.

Album Rating: 4.0

I warmed to Born On A Different Cloud big time recently. Still only a 2.5 though. Possibly a 3.

worst oasis easily. still a few good songs tho

Stop Crying Your Heart Out rules