Album Rating: 5.0

Also even if it did have Waters' vocals ever that's still like half as good as a typical Wright or Gilmour vocal performance

"San Tropez" is freedom.

Album Rating: 5.0

Freedom from good music more like, LOL

































at least I tried guys

I'm not talking about how difficult it is to play, that doesn't mean anything. I mean it lacks any creativity and its lyrics are pretty poor too. It basically has none of the elements that made Floyd such a great band.

The fact that you said Pigs and Sheep can't be among Floyd's best songs because no one rates them as their best (which isn't true at all) and then say San Tropez and Seamus are two of their best songs even though most people consider them to be weak by Floyd's standard suggests to me that you're either a troll or just really dumb when it comes to reasoning. I'll give you the benefit of doubt and go with the former, in which case ignore this post cos I'm just "feeding the troll".

Album Rating: 5.0

I do like Gilmour's voice better than Waters, but on San Tropez he sounds like Gilmour.



And theres nothing wrong with the lyrics. I feel like you are assuming simple = bad.

The only thing bad is this fucking discussion.

Album Rating: 5.0

The fact that you said Pigs and Sheep can't be among Floyd's best songs because no one rates them as their best (which isn't true at all) and then say San Tropez and Seamus are two of their best songs

you're either a troll or just really dumb when it comes to reasoning.

Thanks to bud.

Album Rating: 5.0

lol damn that was good

Album Rating: 5.0

Lol the lyrics to that song are absolutely cringeworthy

"Breaking a stick with a brick on the sand" from the same guy who wrote Time and WYWH is unbelievable

Album Rating: 5.0

Open a book, take a look at the way things stand.

Who gives a fuck? It's a song about vacation. It isn't "Time", it's the exact opposite.

Album Rating: 5.0

Roger Waters doesn't write about good times so well

Either do you. You're killing every good vibe on this web site with this retarded conversation.

Album Rating: 5.0

lol

Mother will they shut the fuck up?

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

I'd like to know how many users have Floyd as their fave band. So far, I know of Rowan, Notrap and ford.

@Lambs:

You never hear anyone putting Three Little Pigs, Sheep or Pigs on the Wing as top Floyd songs, and that is because they aren't top Floyd songs they are just great songs.

Album Rating: 4.5

Are there like ten arguments happening at once here?

Album Rating: 5.0

You haven't even heard my music guest