obviously for lampooning purposes mom!!!!!

"he still has a mewithoutyou 5, theyre basically thrice right"

if it was one of the good mewithoutyou albums i would say no but alas it is not so yes

“obviously for lampooning purposes mom!!!!!”

Then continue on!!!

thank u i needed the motherly support

Album Rating: 5.0

after a revisit to this band's early discog, bumped this right up to its rightful place. While I like No Devolucion more, this is THE emo album of the early 2000s.

Album Rating: 4.5

I did a discog run last month and honestly I still love this but found it a lot harder to listen to than WATT. Ditto on No Devolucion being their peak tho

Full Collapse > War All the Time > Common Existence > Waiting > A City By the Light Divided > No Devolucion

I seem to be the only one who is lukewarm on NO DEVOLUCION. Dunno what it is but I just can't totally grasp it...Feels more like a band trying to emulate Thursday than Thursday themselves.

Album Rating: 5.0

based ranking



mine is p much the same

Album Rating: 4.5

No Devo > WATT > FC > CE > ACBTLD >>> Waiting

Album Rating: 4.5

I will say though City has grown on me a lot since the last time I listened to it

Album Rating: 3.5

this is one of their worst honestly. album slapped when i was younger but its grown off me a lot over the years. pretty fatigued by them exclusively promoting it too lol like you have other records bros



no dev > common existence > war all the time > waiting > this > city

swap this and waiting and then yes perf
will say that if all of Waiting was as good as its best 3ish tracks, it would be a lock for top three thursday

Album Rating: 3.5

what would you say are its best three tracks johnny?

Umm
S: Streaks in the Sky, Where the Circle Ends
A+: Dying in New Brunswick and fuck it, Ian Curtis
B: This Side of Brightness
C: everything else

Album Rating: 3.5

righteous picks def nailed the s tier. always loved tf out of where the circle ends

almost feels like an accident that that song is remotely as good as it is
like, "uh shit okay i guess we'll play a mopey interlude from one of my unused diary entries and then the album can end?" ---- hold it right there Geoff!!

Johnny almost had it but here let me help you.

A: This Side of Brightness; Ian Curtis; Dying in New Brunswick
B: Porcelain; Streaks in the Sky; Where the Circle Ends
B-: In Transmission; The Dotted Line
C: Introduction

Album Rating: 4.5

https://youtu.be/mkZMWQ88-sc



Such an unbelievably awesome set. Geoff's screams sound so good here

Album Rating: 5.0

classic af and i'm tired of pretending it's not

Album Rating: 3.5

what? dont you hype this up all the time as one?

Album Rating: 4.0

cross out the eyes is still amazing.