Circle Takes the Square As the Roots Undo
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


I feel that someguest is the owner of the proper rating. Opposing opinions frighten me, anyway. Individuality is overrated, probably.

fr33convict
October 25th 2010


11723 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Everyones opinion is wrong except mine. In my opinion of course.

Bitchfork
October 25th 2010


7581 Comments


Well, I don't refute that it's supposed to be chaotic. I am just not convinced by the chaos as a whole-- not as much as when the chaos is juxtaposed by the slower sections, anyway.



JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


This is true. We should continue to discuss this quandary via this thread-- and others like it-- until they all know the TRUTH.

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


Yeah, B4k! Quote that shit without a qualifying the statement! Makes my words feel superior or some insanity like that.

=]

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


Hey, ThirtySixChambers! I ummm... uhhh... what I meant was that... and the thing is... see I just thought...

*gulp*

witchxrapist
October 25th 2010


11117 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0



Well, I don't refute that it's supposed to be chaotic. I am just not convinced by the chaos as a whole-- not as much as when the chaos is juxtaposed by the slower sections, anyway.



Uhhh, I'm pretty sure it's supposed to be an aural expression of DEPRESSION. It's not simple juxtaposition of OH LETS PUT A SOFT PART HERE, it's more of the manic switch between when someone freaks out and then breaks down and feels shameful and zombielike, nah mean?

liledman
October 25th 2010


3828 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

the eternal debate rages...

witchxrapist
October 25th 2010


11117 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

lildeman contributes nothing...

fr33convict
October 25th 2010


11723 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I'm not a contributor anyway.

Bitchfork
October 25th 2010


7581 Comments


"Uhhh, I'm pretty sure it's supposed to be an aural expression of DEPRESSION. It's not simple juxtaposition of OH LETS PUT A SOFT PART HERE, it's more of the manic switch between when someone freaks out and then breaks down and feels shameful and zombielike, nah mean?"
it doesn't feel like that at all it feels more like they tried to personify an internal and societal struggle but failed at the internal part of it.

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


@witchxrapist: That's why I understand people having different opinions on this album. Keeping the
concept the artists tried to convey in mind, as of this particular instant, I'm don't think they
achieved the perspective you portrayed. "Non Objective Portrait Of Karma" and "A Crater To Cough In"
are two examples of songs on the album that I enjoyed, and am more inclined to believe in the message
and direction the album intended.

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


I do, ThirtySixChambers, though my exposure to them are fairly limited.

Bitchfork
October 25th 2010


7581 Comments


Witchy you got my track right?

witchxrapist
October 25th 2010


11117 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

it doesn't feel like that at all it feels more like they tried to personify an internal and societal struggle but failed at the internal part of it.


Well then, you're probably misinterpreting it bro. =]

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


I enjoy it. I'm actually watching the filler section now. A few more episodes till it's done. It's interesting, if nothing else. I needed a break from the fight-heavy episodes, or I would have become numb to it all.

Any anime suggestions, ThirtySixChambers?

witchxrapist
October 25th 2010


11117 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0



@witchxrapist: That's why I understand people having different opinions on this album. Keeping the

concept the artists tried to convey in mind, as of this particular instant, I'm don't think they

achieved the perspective you portrayed. "Non Objective Portrait Of Karma" and "A Crater To Cough In"

are two examples of songs on the album that I enjoyed, and am more inclined to believe in the message

and direction the album intended.




Listen to Same Shade As Concrete, that song reminds me of exactly how I felt when I was super depressed in high school. This album in general is something that I could completely relate to during that portion of my life, which is probably why I love it so much, while others don't.

Bitchfork
October 25th 2010


7581 Comments


Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?Witchy you got my track right?


Same Shade as Concrete is my third-least favorite track on here.

JustJoe.
October 25th 2010


10944 Comments


@witchxrapist: Will listen, definitely. Spun this album twice today, so I think that I'll start fresh
with it tomorrow. Being late to the party has its disadvantages.

@ThirtySixChambers: WhatTheJesus?! Thanks, ThirtySixChambers! I'll be all over those the minute next
weekend begins.

liledman
October 25th 2010


3828 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

ill contribute by saying that the album is fairly overrated though i still enjoy it.



but most of the arguments for the album being classic really get on my nerves, as it usually has something to do with chaos vs tranquility being emotional depth. its not like they are musical luminaries for employing dynamics.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy