Album Rating: 4.5

Too hard to rank, but Serpent is easily the worst and Marrow was my biggest grower. Also Faustian Echoes = Serpent, the White EP = best EP, and Of Stone, Wind, and Pillor is one of the best songs they've ever written.

I'm pretty sure I think Serpent is top 2 or 3 and was mindblown at the negative reception it receives, but I really haven't listened to this band in several years so I'll get back to you.

Album Rating: 3.5

Serpent is cool m/

Album Rating: 4.5

It's a good album, I'd be stoked if I wrote it, but we're also comparing it to albums like every other Agalloch album. I listen to it sometimes.

Album Rating: 4.0

Mantle > Ashes > Folklore > Marrow > Serpent, but the White EP > Marrow & Serpent



Agreed 100%.

Album Rating: 4.5

Also agreed with that.

Album Rating: 4.3

[3] that's my exact ranking too

Album Rating: 4.0

I had to read through the ranking 5 times to understand it. I was having a dense moment. It's clearly a LP rating, with the caveat that the White EP is also better than Marrow and Serpent.

Their first 4 LPs are all legitimate choices, I just don't agree with the notion that Marrow is somehow inferior. I think it's down to personal preference and some fans simply didn't like the change in direction.

Album Rating: 4.5

It’s not inferior by any means. The first 3 are stone cold classics though.

Album Rating: 3.9 | Sound Off

Sorry Demon, I just wanted to show my love for the White EP.



"Their first 4 LPs are all legitimate choices, I just don't agree with the notion that Marrow is somehow inferior. I think it's down to personal preference and some fans simply didn't like the change in direction."



Totally agree with that, Marrow is still a strong 4 in my book.

Album Rating: 4.3

I love Marrow, it's 8.5/10 as you can see from my rating. I just love the first three and The White a little more. One of the best bands ever.

Album Rating: 4.5

Yes.

Album Rating: 4.5

I miss them on a monthly basis, but at least they left us this amazing legacy.

Album Rating: 5.0

Almost THE album for me. Black Lake goes on a BIT too long, dropping this from 'the best' to #2 behind Ashes

Album Rating: 4.0

At least you have the top 2 correct, even if I just about prefer this.

Album Rating: 4.5

The melotron on Black Lake is the best thing on this album.

Album Rating: 4.5

Ashes=The Mantle=Pale Folklore=Marrow>>Serpent

Album Rating: 5.0

Mellotron [2]

On monolith too

Album Rating: 4.0

This didn't click with me as much as The Mantle, Pale Folklore and Ashes. But it has been while since I last listened to this. Perhaps I need to revisit this.

I honestly like this album better than Pale Folklore. It's not as good as The Mantle or Ashes but it is special. It has a one-of-a-kind atmosphere and some of their best songs.