Dream Theater The Astonishing
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
djr2
January 31st 2016


31 Comments


That and the story is all over the place and you have to go outside the album to figure out what characters are and their nicknames. Lord nefaryus is nicknamed bug. Why? Never explained until you see it on the official site. Nomac backstory? None in the album, but yea theres an explanation on the website!! This list goes on and on... Sigh I guess I'm just a sucker for story albums which is why I rated it this high, that and it fits my "transition" from heavier music to softer music, if you can believe that.

Underflow
January 31st 2016


5297 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

I just don't understand why someone would listen to this when Rush did the same idea in 20 minutes. Then again, I don't understand why someone would listen to Rush, so maybe I'm just a lost cause. Throw me some Hawkwind.

djr2
January 31st 2016


31 Comments


It's not really the same as 2112, similarities of course, but not exactly the same. I could be wrong though, its been a while since I listened to that album.

Underflow
January 31st 2016


5297 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

Musically, no, but the concept is basically the same. That said there are multiple Rush nods here.

djr2
January 31st 2016


31 Comments


Very true. The stories do start out the same but the ending is different (spoiler: the leader of the empire gives in and powers down the nomacs after music magically restores faythe to life after being stabbed to death.) 2112's ending is the empire taking over everything and leaving music behind, and the main character commiting suicide.

And yes, 2112 is performed and done better. Simpler, easier, and you dont have to research the album outside of... Well... The album.

Voltimand
January 31st 2016


1670 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

"Then again, I don't understand why someone would listen to Rush"



For those sweet, sweet drums n bass.

Gleam
January 31st 2016


438 Comments


Replying to @Titan, it's ok, I love discussing music. I'm not exactly new here, it's been a long time since I discovered this site and followed what's new around here, but only now I actually signed up and built an account. Nice talking to you!

Mythodea
January 31st 2016


7459 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Then again, I don't understand why someone would listen to Rush





Do you even prog?

Gleam
January 31st 2016


438 Comments


"Then again, I don't understand why someone would listen to Rush"

I mean, come on now. Rush are pretty damn epic.

ksoflas
January 31st 2016


1511 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

DT on the one hand coped succesfully with the depart of Kevin Moore but on the other hand the loss of Mike Portnoy meant the bitter end of the band itself.

someguest
January 31st 2016


30519 Comments


Now we're naming our albums The adjective?

These guys haven't been in school for awhile.

sam1oq
January 31st 2016


106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

DT on the one hand coped succesfully with the depart of Kevin Moore but on the other hand the loss of Mike Portnoy meant the bitter end of the band itself.




Disagree. Portnoy was making the band ridiculous and driving them in a direction the rest of the band wasn't comfortable with except for JP maybe. They just grew apart musically. Portnoy wanted to do heavy stuff and the rest wanted to go back to a more melodic sound. The last albums together were not so good. They had some cool moments (Octavarium, ITPOE, TCOT etc.), but the lyrics were awful and the music was turning bland.

Emyay
January 31st 2016


6282 Comments


no way i'm even listening to a second of this

Titan
January 31st 2016


26569 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

'Then again, I don't understand why someone would listen to Rush











Do you even prog?'

You don't have to prog in order to RUSHHHHHHHH

Underflow
January 31st 2016


5297 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

Sorry, I should have clarified: 70's Rush. 80's Rush is where it's at.

Ocean of Noise
January 31st 2016


11368 Comments


80s Rush is generally better than 70s Rush but both eras rule.

someguest
January 31st 2016


30519 Comments


Yes is the only huge prog band worth a damn.

in b4 floyd - floyd was never prog. art rock brah.

Underflow
January 31st 2016


5297 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

"in b4 floyd - floyd was never prog. art rock brah." Truer words have rarely been spoken.

Ocean of Noise
January 31st 2016


11368 Comments


Yeah they were never terribly proggy

climactic
January 31st 2016


22921 Comments


might listen to this for lols



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy