Album Rating: 4.0

haha it's cool if I rated speak now there would be a 5 in there so

Album Rating: 4.0

1. put all of your numbers in a bag

2. put that bag on my penis

Album Rating: 4.5

Self Starter 4.5

Other Side 4.5

Type Three 4.5

Modern Age 4.5

Little Tyrants 4

Desires 4

Someone Anyone 3.5

Intentions 3

Innocent 2.5

Gods, Drugs, and Sex 2.5

Orpheum 2.5



True list. Time for Cities



(*fin) 5

Unwinding Cable Car 4.5

A Whisper and a Clamor 4.5

Dismantle.Repair 4.5

Inevitable 4.5

Godspeed 4

Reclusion 4

Alexithymia 3.5

Adelaide 3.5

There is No Mathematics... 3.0

Hello Alone 2.5



When you put it this way, it makes sense that Cities>Vital

Album Rating: 4.5

3.636 vs. 3.955 for Cities



Then again if we're ranking songs being imprecise (e.g., 1-10 scale) makes this whole list pointless

Album Rating: 4.5

Unwinding Cable Car is like a 3 at best

Album Rating: 4.5

no

Album Rating: 4.0

sigh more lists, can't resist



*(fin) 5

Alexithymia 4.75

Dismantle.Repair. 4.75

Godspeed 4.5

Inevitable 4.5

Unwinding Cable Car 4.5

Adelaide 4

Whisper & a Clamor 4

Reclusion 3.5

Mathematics 3.25

Hello Alone 2.5

Album Rating: 4.0

but yeah honestly albums are almost never the sum of their parts, i'm just doing this list for kicks

Album Rating: 4.5

yeahh, UWCC 4.5/5



take that FromDaHood!

Album Rating: 4.0

dude that bridge. "in and out of the DAAAAAARRRKKKK"

goosebumps every time.

Album Rating: 4.5

The bridge is actually my least favorite part. Specifically the first half... "You're so brilliant/Don't soon forget." But when it gets to the "This is the correlation..." part, yeah it gets pretty awesome.

Album Rating: 4.0

Hope I'm not too late to the ranking party! Imma gonna do it a bit differently since I don't think I can give the individual songs a number though and/or because of my constant need to be different than everyone else.



Vital Favorites

Little Tyrants - Other Side - Desires - Intentions - Modern Age



Great

Self Starter - Someone Anyone - God, Drugs & Sex, Orpheum



Good

Innocent - Type 3



Cities Favorites

Godspeed - Reclusion - Unwinding Cable Car - No Mathematics to Love and Loss



Great

Alexithymia - Dismantle, Repair - Fin



Good

Inevitable - Adelaide - Hello Alone



Meh

A Whisper & A Clamor



Vital wins for me if I look at it this way... I also don't think that individual track ratings would have to equal out to your rating of the entire album. Looking at an album as a whole and then as individual songs can be be completely different. I've had albums that I loved all the songs off of, but when I look at the entire package it hurts it because of things like weird pacing, songs that don't belong or songs that sound too much like each other, etc. etc.

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Damn. Surprised everybody is digging this so hard.

Album Rating: 4.5

A 3 for Unwinding Cable Car? A "meh" for A Whisper and A Clamor?



This is blasphemy I tell you! Blasphemy!



Yeah Kj, I think the slower songs on this make this noticeably worse than Cities but maybe that's just

me. Besides a 3.5 isn't bad at all.

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

It's definitely an enjoyable record, but even as this is new, I still find myself wanting to jam all the older stuff more.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

"Vital wins for me if I look at it this way... I also don't think that individual track ratings would have to equal out to your rating of the entire album. Looking at an album as a whole and then as individual songs can be be completely different. I've had albums that I loved all the songs off of, but when I look at the entire package it hurts it because of things like weird pacing, songs that don't belong or songs that sound too much like each other, etc. etc"





^^^Totally agree with you, Ecnalzen.

5/5

Album Rating: 4.0

Right on, Storm. Glad I am not the only one with that mindset.

Album Rating: 2.0

not sure how one can complain about this being obnoxious and pretentious while giving really high marks to the likes of brand new, radiohead, sufjan, and converge but okay whatevs

Album Rating: 2.0

the word overused is overused!