Album Rating: 2.5

Eh, I don't know about it measuring up to the others, but to each their own. I'm going to listen to this a bit more, but I'm just not really feeling it.

Album Rating: 1.5

How is this any different from the post grunge/hard rock we all love to bash?



Besides maybe some of the lyrics that can be a bit Brand New-esque?

Album Rating: 2.5

yeah i feel the same way as sniff. i think thrice has a legacy on sputnik which contributes heavily to it. this album is pretty w.e barring 2 songs. it really does seem like the radio rock we bash for being generic

Album Rating: 4.0

I still haven't listened to this one. Should I? I was hyping it up and everything, but then decided to pass it up. lol

Album Rating: 2.5

nah. just listen to salt and shadow, which is the best thing they've done in years

Album Rating: 2.8

listen to the bookend tracks for sure

Album Rating: 3.7

The Long Defeat into Seneca and Death from Above are essentials

Album Rating: 2.8

Death from Above is ok. Feel like it's being pretty hugely overrated just because the chorus sounds somewhat Vheissu-ish, but the lyrics are pretty awful and the mix makes the vocals kind of grating

Album Rating: 1.5

I found Seneca to be the most interesting and best thing on here. That't says quite a lot how I feel about this.

Album Rating: 4.9

u guys all have a different fav song in this alleged blah blah blah thrice album, so its clearly a 4.9 classic and my rating is right

Album Rating: 4.0

stay with me's simple chorus works to its benefit

Album Rating: 4.0

acad speaks the truth

Album Rating: 3.0

I DROPPED DEATH OUT OF THESKYYYYYYYYYYY

Album Rating: 4.0

I agree with that for sure. Don't know if I'd go all the way to a 4.9 but a 4.5 is definitely operative. A 3.8 doesn't do it justice that's for sure. I think too many hold this band's standards too high. Like almost like Brand New or something luls

Album Rating: 4.0

*shouts into the void* because this band is better than brand new

Album Rating: 4.0

Album gets better every time I listen to it. Stay With Me is song of the year thus far for me!

Album Rating: 4.0

in light of recent events Blood on the Sand just hit like 1000000x times harder

Album Rating: 5.0

The 3.8 is LOW. Especially if you use M/m as a reference point, as this is a huge improvement from Mm. The replay value of this record is absurd, the production is amazing, the songs are expertly crafted, Dustin sounds amazing, the guitar tones have never been better, and it highlights all the things Thrice do best. Think I have spun this about 30 times now and I can see this record standing tall next to Vheissu. Feel bad for those who can't appreciate this amazing record. I predict the rating will go up with time and this record will age beautifully.

Album Rating: 4.0

hm agreed tbh



oh wait, this isn't the Beggars thread? Nevermind.

stay with me reminds me of the reason by hoobastank