Album Rating: 2.0

Holy shit that cover was awful and I ain't even heard the original.

Album Rating: 4.5

RIP Dave Brockie

RIP thread. Row deserves better.

^pretty much

Album Rating: 3.2

^ bumped down that 5 did ya



Quality of this really drops off after Divorce

Album Rating: 5.0

Finally decided on a rating for this.

@Jack, yeah my 5 was mostly just for hype cause I'm digging this so much. Can't say I agree about the quality dropping off after divorce tho. The thunderbird inn kicks ass and I also love you ain't no saint

Album Rating: 4.0

Best songs:

St. Joe Keeps Us Safe

Divorce and The American South

The Thunderbird Inn

You Ain't No Saint



*tbh this is probably not a 5, hype got the best of me.

they're just ratings on a website tho. I see Cygnatti 5 albums he's digging quite often and then he lowers them to a 3.5 lol

Album Rating: 2.0

Oh shucks, Atari. I'm just hoppin' aboard the hype train and then re-ratin' once the hype train does out. :x



My rym ratings are always the real deal tho.

Album Rating: 4.0

^ I have tons of albums I havn't even heard rated at 4's... its my way of flagging an album to listen to in the future :X

Album Rating: 2.5

atleast this is better than the last The Wonder Years album, but both are still ridiculously overrated by sputfanboys lol

@Cyg, dude i do the same thing sometimes when I'm hyped about an album i was just using you as an example :D

Album Rating: 4.0

@adr Yeah you already said that last page man thanks for your varied input

Album Rating: 2.5

yea must be on the main review page, thanks

HEY HOLY GHOST, WHY'D YOU LEAVE ME WHERE'D YOU GO?

RIGHT WHEN I FUCKING NEEED YOUUU

I'M ALL ALONE

Album Rating: 4.5

^^I think Grapefruit has become my favorite song to listen to at the moment.



So long, I'm sorry that I wasn't who you wanted. If I can't make you happy, I'm no good for anyone.

Album Rating: 3.2

I would love You Ain't No Saint but there's a feedback thing that makes Dan go horribly off-key for like one line and it's just so unfortunate

Album Rating: 3.9

Yeah that song's the weak point here but cmon dude the Thunderbird Inn is life

Album Rating: 3.9

You still haven't read the review how dare you show your face in here