Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Yeah this album has a high emotional value.

Basically it's a 4+1.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

"It doesn't matter. I have not checked a single note from their 80's material, so I don't have any feedback to rely on and make comparisons. Besides, 80's or 70's, it's still PF, so how bad can it be ?"



Yeah, it's still Floyd, the best band ever. It's far from being a bad album.

Album Rating: 4.0

"Should I dig this ?"



I think you will. There's nothing bad with this one and David Gilmour's performance is excellent. It's easier to get into than a lot of their other albums too.

Album Rating: 4.5

Album is superb, man. Check it out.

Album Rating: 2.0

Good review. I just got around to reading it, sorry it took so long. I enjoyed your take on the review, though obviously our opinions on the album differ greatly. High Hopes is definitely a great tune, so I guess there we do see eye to eye.



Anyway, POS'd.

Album Rating: 3.9

ah well thanks anyway man, being as you're staff anything I can improve on?

Album Rating: 2.0

I'm actually still trying to live up to my title actually haha. but I really didn't see anything major wrong with it. It was very informative and pretty well articulated.

Album Rating: 3.9

haha well either way I'm sure you have some good advice

but thanks man I appreciate it

Album Rating: 3.0

ahem... MEDDLE >

Agreed and it's not even close.

Album Rating: 3.0

Top Floyd? Well it's mine even though it isn't their best, and I don't know anyone here who felt that before me. I can't pick fairly between Animals and WYWH, then Darkside, they're all equal

For me it goes:
Animals
WYWH
Meddle
Darkside

Album Rating: 3.9

Are there any others threads you'd like to bring that up in? I get the point.

Album Rating: 3.0

So close for me, they all have their(I shouldn't say but I feel it) let downs, that I feel are all equal overall.

Animals doesn't have any let downs for me. Neither does WYWH. That's why those two are my Floyd 5's.

Album Rating: 3.0

I get that. Meddle just has this something that makes it so personal and close for me

Album Rating: 2.0

@Wack

Meddle rules. Not my absolute favourite, but "Echoes" is, I think, the greatest song Pink floyd ever wrote.



Not that anyone cares, but my personal ranking goes:

Dark side

Animals

Meddle (above Wish only because "Echoes" and "Pillow")

Wish You Were Here

Piper

Wall

Saucerful

Atom

Ummagumma



- the rest vary.

Album Rating: 3.9

Interesting ranking SgtPepper but damn WYWH so low

Album Rating: 2.0

In all honesty, Wish and Meddle are tied for third. Meddle takes it just barely, mainly because "Pillow" is otherworldly, and "Echoes" is just... don't even get me started.

Album Rating: 3.0

but "Echoes" is, I think, the greatest song Pink floyd ever wrote.



Alot of people say that but still One Of These Days, Fearless, Pillow Of Winds, and San Tropez left a deep personally impacting impression. It's just the most personal PF album for me