Album Rating: 5.0
Wright was the only one worthy
Damn that makes me fucking sad
RIP
|
| |
obviously?
Well yeah, Lake has much more power and range in his voice.
Honestly I think Shine On sounds perfect the way it is. You can hear Gilmour singing it on post-Roger live recordings and it's just not as powerful.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Well I mean Lake has the range yeah but Gilmour's vocals just get to me like no others do so we'll just agree to disagree yeah
The post-live recordings are still great, but inferior; its not really because of Gilmour's vocals though its just they never play the full thing
|
| |
Well I mean Lake has the range yeah but Gilmour's vocals just get to me like no others do so we'll just agree to disagree yeah
Well no it seems we actually agree here. Lake has the range and technical ability and Gilmour has the emotion. Keep up Rowan.
The post-live recordings are still great, but inferior; its not really because of Gilmour's vocals though its just they never play the full thing
I'm talking specifically about the vocal section, not the whole song.
|
| |
why wage war over politics
when we can rage war over FAV PINK FLOYD SONGS MWHAHAHA
|
| |
its perf as it is doesnt matter anyway
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Well you said they were about tied whereas I said much as I like Lake, Gilmour is leagues ahead so KEEP UP JAMIE
Potsy do you like Piper?
|
| |
Yeah we disagree hard there but not about the particular point you were talking about in your previous post.
|
| |
Potsy do you like Piper?
i dont remember silentpotatos ratings are gone
|
| |
is it sad that i used to rely on sputnik ratings to remind myself whether i liked something i hadn't heard in a long time or not?
|
| |
always wondered how much recall dudes with 3k+ ratings have
like havey has over 4k how much of those 4k records can he remember
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
So JT, are you saying we should agree to disagree except for the part we agree on? cool
You should give it another spin potsy, I remember rec'ing that album to you when I was but a fresh young'un like a year ago
How time goes
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Oh hello tom
|
| |
sup
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
How much recall?
Total recall.
|
| |
always wondered how much recall dudes with 3k+ ratings have
ocd music listening has its ups and its downs
ups is that i can literally appreciate the good in any genre now/infinitely more open minded about music and it also is a key factor in my musical abilities i think
downs is that you forget about amazing records for years
|
| |
Yes that's what I'm saying, Rowan.
|
| |
You should give it another spin potsy
will do my beau.
im pretty sure i liked it decently
i do remember there being one really fucking trippy song that i thought was cool
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
You just couldn't resist could you zak
|
| |
nice nice
|
| |
|
|
