Album Rating: 3.5

mine would go



Zooey > poop > JTFU

Album Rating: 3.5

Remember when you used to be funny, Zach?

Album Rating: 3.5

:hi5:

Album Rating: 3.5

hey zach, remember when you didn't post here for a while



that would come in handy right nowThis Message Edited On 01.26.08

Album Rating: 3.5

Thank you for proving my point.

Album Rating: 3.5

this is me not posting

Album Rating: 4.5

Thrice have evolved. Great album.

sounds like a pretty chill band. Have to check these guys out :thumb:

I changed my rating to a 5 and I don't feel guilty about it...I mean there's just not one bad or even mediocre song to me on either disc.
Plus, having finally listened to The Illusion of Safety, I can see Thrice's progression and I feel like a proud parent watching their kid grow up. Even though this kid still slayed when he was little.

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm thinking the Air disc will probably be the best of the 4.

Arg I put it pack down to a 4.5. It's not a classic, but it's better than a 4.5. This is probably my favorite 4.5 album.

Album Rating: 3.5

over-rated

It's not hxc enough

over-rated

Album Rating: 3.0

^total agreement. I want to like them but they are just way to bland and since everyone on this site praises them i think im missing something. I just think they are boring and repetitive. They have a few great tracks and then 20 other tracks that sound kinda like those few great tracks.

I want to like them but they are just way to bland and since everyone on this site praises them i think im missing something. I just think they are boring and repetitive. They have a few great tracks and then 20 other tracks that sound kinda like those few great tracks.

Album Rating: 3.0

I have listened to it quite a few times. The fire disk all sounds alike as well as the Water to their individual disks. I ve listend to a lot of their stuff and i dnt really see this PROGRESSION. Sure they did a concept album with an iteresting topic but it wasn't really anything special imo. Digital Sea-awesome track. Open Water a lot of the same. On the fire side Firebreather and Burn the Fleet are just boring while The Messenger and The Flame Deluge are great.

Progression means they have developed more and are able to make a full album that is unique but fits. Listening to this it's like This is the fire album so we'll play our aggressive songs and we'll just talk about fire so it fits. This is the Water so we'll put these chilled out songs next to each other and as long as we mention water it's a concept.

I didn't see any elitist in your comments I just don't really see this as anything special. Fair to Midland is great though thanks for the recommend i just got the album two days ago and i love it.

I'll smile at you but i don't think i'm ready to hug.This Message Edited On 02.28.08

What albums have you heard? The progression from The Illusion of Safety to this album is unreal. But what makes Thrice so great imo is that even though they've come along way in developing their sound, they've always been solid and pretty original in the post hardcore world.

Album Rating: 3.0

The Illusion of Safety and Vheissu. I worded my last comment wrong. There is progression but i don't think it's as album-writers if that makes any sense. Thrice is just a band, at least for me, that has some great tracks but whenever i listen to a whole album of theirs a get bored. By progression before i didnt mean as artist but more as writers of an entire piece of music that works together.

They just need to work on making a great album that stays fresh and doesn't sound samey at points. They're just a case of good that doesn't take the risk to be great. At least to me thats the case.

Ahhh I see. You're a wonderful little explainer you are.