Nice to see someone else who doesn't like this.

Album Rating: 5.0

Podrick with the crushing pagebreak : (

Album Rating: 5.0

it's okay not to like stuff. it's lame to be a wanna be monocle-wearing, pipe smoking, circle jerk-argument critic in a comment section on sput

Album Rating: 5.0

Yea that 'critique' was pure cringe. Like it's gotta be trolling.



ChatGPT Prompt: "Write me a sput soundoff for Karnivool's new album that makes me sound like a Fantano fanfic writer high off my own farts"

Standard reviewing tone, that is.

Personally, Themata is one of the best alternative metal albums I've ever heard, Sound Awake is massive if a little overblown and Asymmetry is confusing, but very refreshing after the previous two. This one just keeps meandering most of the time.

Album Rating: 5.0

No, what you just said is standard reviewer tone.



All anyone has ever done on sput is to share their opinion. No one's opinion is superior to anyone elses'. Presenting something you don't like as not "holding up to critical scrutiny" is laughable (like the comment in question). It makes it seem as though the writer of the comment believes they have some special privilege to critique things that the rest of us don't. Maybe they would have a point if they weren't bang off the consensus.

I'd agree but the final sentence sinks your entire comment.

Memento's post is dumb, should've been a soundoff instead of a comment, but the others' reactions are blown out of proportion. Almost as if y'all were just pissed at a negative opinion about the album and the "wannabe critic" argument was just an excuse to turn the entire thread into a rant...

Album Rating: 5.0

Nah I don't worry that he doesn't like it lol .. doesn't affect my enjoyment in the slightest.

Album Rating: 4.5

Dork/10, band is cool and I bet they have big sex with girls

11/10 post