Album Rating: 4.5

Knives Out coming on after Treefingers would be abysmal what

Album Rating: 4.0

And how is Optimistic better? I suppose it depends if you want to rip up the formula completely, or just replace Optimistic with a better (vaguely similar) song. If you think Kid A’s flow is destroyed somewhat by Optimistic’s placement, then yeah just replace it with something entirely different, or (hypothetically) rearrange the track-listing.

Album Rating: 4.5

optimistic is one of my favourite songs and i can't really imagine replacing it (i will admit that it's a bit of a odd one within Kid A, but i like how it switches it up). But if i were to replace it, then i might be wrong would be my pick, i think it would sound great between treefingers and in limbo

Album Rating: 4.0

Excellent choice, one of the better tracks here.

• Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box 7
• Pyramid Song 10
• Pulk / Pull Revolving Doors 5
• You and Whose Army? 9
• I Might Be Wrong 8
• Knives Out 7
• Morning Bell / Amnesiac 8
• Dollars and Cents 8
• Hunting Bears 5
• Like Spinning Plates 9
• Life in a Glasshouse 10

Knives Out 2 points behind Army and Spinning Plates smdh, please call a cab sir

• Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box 6.0
• Pyramid Song 8.0
• Pulk / Pull Revolving Doors 7.0
• You and Whose Army? 5.0
• I Might Be Wrong 7.5
• Knives Out 6.5
• Morning Bell / Amnesiac 4.5
• Dollars and Cents 6.0
• Hunting Bears 5.0
• Like Spinning Plates 8.0
• Life in a Glasshouse 4.0

You say that like Army and Spinning Plates aren't masterworks ????

Ghandhi's is better hmm. I'd say

• Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box 6.5
• Pyramid Song 9.0
• Pulk / Pull Revolving Doors 6.0
• You and Whose Army? 6.0
• I Might Be Wrong 8.0
• Knives Out 9.0
• Morning Bell / Amnesiac 5.0 (hard RIP for the best track on Kid A)
• Dollars and Cents 7.5
• Hunting Bears 5.0
• Like Spinning Plates 7.0
• Life in a Glasshouse 7.0

Album Rating: 4.5

Just gonna give my two cents:

Packt: 7

Pyramid Song: 10

Pulk/Pull: 7

You and Whose Army: 9

I Might Be Wrong: 8

Knives Out: 9

Morning Bell/Amnesiac: 6

Dollars and Cents: 7

Hunting Bears: 5

Like Spinning Plates: 8

Life in a Glasshouse: 10



Seeing those ratings, my 4.5 overall for this may be a bit of a stretch, but I actually think this one is a bit better than the sum of its parts - when I'm in the right mood. Pyramid and Glasshouse definitely lift it up a lot though. An excellent complement to Kid A, in fact I've probably listened to this more than I have Kid A in recent years.

Album Rating: 4.5

Packt - 10

Pyramid -song 10 (best song ever)

Pull/pulk - 6

Army - 8

I might be wrong - 10

Knives out - 9

Morning bell - 6 (hard RIP for the best track on Kid A [2])

Dollars - 8

Hunting bears - 9 (underrated af)

Like spinning plates - 9

Life in a glasshouse 9

i might be wrong is most certainly a 10

knives out is super overrated and doesnt even scratch the top half of songs here for me. i might be wrong, packt, pyramind song, army, like spinning plates, and life in a glass house are all better

you might be wrong

names half the album and doesn't mention Dollars and Cents smh

Kid A's 'Morning Bell' is obviously the better of the two, but the Amnesiac version is still awesome, especially as a kind of diffusive experiment. Same content, different context type of thing. In fact, this version might not be as good without the direct counterpoint of the Kid A version. Y'all be trippin'.

Album Rating: 4.5

This version's morning bell sounds a bit off to me. I think it misses the beats that drive the kid a version forward so well

Literally correct if I'm counting correctly - Kid A version is 5/4, but this one is 4/4?

Album Rating: 4.5

Thats interesting if so. Actually didn't know that

I wish you were in 5/4