Album Rating: 4.5

amazing album

Album Rating: 4.0

it's tied with Rainbow Signs as my #1 mwY track.



best Sowing take right here

Album Rating: 3.8

tbh I kinda agree with YoYo on this one. Michael is a potentially good song Will Yip'd beyond the point of no return

I had a dream (srsly) where I heard the true version of Michael and it was so good imma never need to jam this one again
Julia/Dormouse/New Wine/W&B>>>everything else here

Album Rating: 3.8

agreed with everything typed but even more based take: the three best songs from these sessions are all on the EP (August, Bethlehem, Cities in that order)



New Winesburgohio prob fourth

Album Rating: 4.5

New Wine New Skins is my fav mwY song, which is funny considering this conversation because it immediately precedes Michael Jackson Thrilller

Album Rating: 5.0

Dormouse Sighs is the best mwY song, fact

Album Rating: 4.5

glad you’re always there with the August love, rowan - one of my all time faves

Album Rating: 3.8

hell yeah man, everything from GUERNICA on is S-tier

Album Rating: 4.5

even the build up to that part is so good. I actually just got the matte tour print they commissioned for that song:



https://halfhazardpress.com/products/mewithoutyou-fall-tour

I miss when that EP dropped and everyone had two months of being feverishly excited for this
Was worth the hype tbh, even if it didn't have the same staying power as TS or PH

Album Rating: 4.0

agreed with everything typed but even more based take: the three best songs from these sessions are all on the EP (August, Bethlehem, Cities in that order) [2]



GOAT EP

Album Rating: 4.5

Dormouse Sighs is the best mwY song, fact





then why hast thou not spelt it by doth including the brackets and doth excluding the letters of the capital variety

Album Rating: 4.5

Julia is such an amazing tune.



Love this album.

Album Rating: 4.5

have I made myself

MYSELF CLEAR?!

Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah I'm listening to this now and damn I just don't know if PH can ever top it lmao

Album Rating: 4.0

This one's damn good, but I think Brother Sister will always be my personal fave

Album Rating: 4.5

Should probably bump this.



Only song I don't dig is Michael, the rest is class.

Album Rating: 5.0

Brother, Sister was my favorite forever until Ten Stories, Pale Horses, and [Untitled] all overtook it, ha.



"Only song I don't dig is Michael, the rest is class."

Michael is possibly their best song, tied with Rainbow Signs

Album Rating: 4.5

Huh, I just don't vibe with it that much.



Julia, Dormouse Sighs & New Wine, New Skins would be my top 3 here.