Their #2 is my #1 so they almost got it right. I was expecting "This is America" to top the list but they went for the other woke zeitgeisty song.

I like the Robyn, esp the run of songs from track 4 on...but none of the individual tracks are so amazing taken out of that run for me, more they add up to something more interesting as a group of nostalgic 'the sounds of my youth' love letters

Album Rating: 1.0

You guys pay attention to p4k way too much

Looks like their top 10 will have 1975, Cardi B and that Mitski bore... quite dismal overall.

I mean the Cupcakke...a song about the glans looking like a turkey...well it's Christmas themed I guess

Pour some sugar on me...I mean gravy

Pitchfork are doing a good job of making me think new music should be outlawed, luckily we know it ain't this bad

Their picks have the longevity of appeal of pop up ads, most of them scream novelty. Esp the Cupcakke one, I mean wtf lol?

That top 10 have made Kacey Musgraves at 11 sound a bit better...at least different.

Still sounds deeply average overall to me though - pop sounds mixed with banjo has captured the imagination, quite a nice combo I'll admit, boring arrangement, tedious lyrics and intermittently twee vox.

So far so bored by this list.

'Looks like their top 10 will have 1975, Cardi B and that Mitski bore... quite dismal overall.'

Yes, plus Snail Mail too maybe just to lower the pulse rate a little more.

First there was The Walking Dead...now behold The Listening Dead P4k zombies

Ok found one 5/5 song on the list - Jessica Pratt 'This Time Around' is a winner, knew there'd be one

Album Rating: 3.5

pitchfork is still good for a laugh

I don’t even hate love it if we made it, but #1 in 2018!?!?!? Cringe.

Album Rating: 2.5

Midnight City is a hard 5/5 lol. That whole album is an easy 5

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

I'm honestly more impressed that of all the Lil Peep songs released in 2018 they chose the only genuinely bad one

The quote that they chose for that cupcakke song is maximal possible cringe.

“I thought I came but I peed on the dick.” How to not make nolan listen to an artist 101.

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Tbf Duck Duck Goose is genuinely one of the best songs of the year so they got that one right at least

Love it If We Made it is extremely bad but I actually really like It's Not Living so idk whether this is worth a listen or not

I actually quite enjoyed the Cupcakke song but no way near to a top 10 songs of the year degree

Is that word supposed to rhyme with bukakke or something

I’m not even really making fun of the cupcakke song, I’m making fun of pitchfork acting like “peeing on the dick” is a smart lyric

Album Rating: 2.5

Pitchfork has gotten so awful in recent years, I really despise what they’ve become.



If I wanted to listen to The Downtown Lights, I’d listen to The Downtown Lights, not some half baked rework with political nothing buzzwords just thrown in there

gave this a listen last night.
it's got some good stuff but it's a little overlong which makes it tough to really rate