Album Rating: 4.0

:O

you're dead to me : (

Album Rating: 5.0

those words sting

Album Rating: 4.0

its ok i forgiv you



But Justice still my fav Metallica album hehehe

Album Rating: 5.0

< 3

Album Rating: 4.5

Pika needs rehab. St.Anger on full throttle for 9 consecutive days. Mission accomplished.

Album Rating: 4.0

the doom element is pretty mild on half these songs - and Nick is actively trying to sing like Hetfield



still don't get it, black album has some classic tunes

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm only saying all this because this last week I listened to the black album twice for the first time in about 5 years - and honestly I enjoyed it a lot

Album Rating: 5.0

I'm just going to be cheeky and say it's an age thing for me. I was one year and one day old when it came out :p

Album Rating: 4.0

so you were a twinkle in your daddy's eye for the black album



I mean the release dates are 4 years apart, not a long period of time

Album Rating: 4.0

the black album is a bit more commercial

Album Rating: 5.0

Black album taught me drums. Damn classic right there.

Album Rating: 3.5

--Icon also sounds like Metallica except for a few songs. Also, I am not shy about loving Black Album.--

No way. Icon doesn't sound like Metallica musically or vocally. I also like the Black Album, I'm just being a smart ass.



--Metallica's last good album was Master of Puppets. Everything after was trash.--

... And Justice is easily their best album... just saying.



--This has better and more memorable songwriting than Icon.--

A majority of Icon is classic stuff. Only 'Poison' and 'Shallow Seasons' aren't classic Paradise Lost songs. This has "Hallowed Land", "Forever Failure", and "Once Solemn".

Album Rating: 5.0

".. And Justice is easily their best album... just saying."



Lolno and it's not even close



"A majority of Icon is classic stuff. Only 'Poison' and 'Shallow Seasons' aren't classic Paradise Lost songs. This has "Hallowed Land", "Forever Failure", and "Once Solemn"."



I don't disagree, I got both rated at 4.5. This is just more enjoyable, but as far as by how much, there isn't a lot between the two.

Album Rating: 4.5

Imo Draconian Times is more refined and polished. You can hear on the Last Time the band's effort to break the chains and gain some air play. Icon is darker, more claustrophobic and less ethereal. I enjoy both and not only. Great discography, even Host rules. Btw, of course AJFA is easily top 3 Metallica, at least better than Ride..

Album Rating: 5.0

For me AJFA is on the same level of blandness as DM or Hardwired - not outright terrible but nothing to write home about.



Ride is the best Metallica agreed

Album Rating: 5.0

Best Metallica is MoP what the hell boys!

PL over Metallica anyday as a band tbh

Album Rating: 4.0

there's always one I guess

"Only 'Poison' and 'Shallow Seasons' aren't classic Paradise Lost songs"

Willie bro Poison is the worst for sure imo but how is Shallow Seasons not classic PL? The first 30 seconds are one of my favorite moments in the entire discography (pure goth!) and Holmes' delivery after that is so frenzied, in the "the thoughts ARISING, there's no DISGUISING WHERE YOU'VE BEEEN" bit he sounds like a deranged priest or something.

Album Rating: 4.5

This has some major jams. Hallowed Ground fucking rips.