What Omair said essentially.

Album Rating: 5.0

No it's not. Even if that was the case did you read a word the guys just said?

Even if it is, doing a rehash of that album would essentially be that: A rehash. It would not be nearly as good as the original. Trying too hard to duplicate an album usually leads to an album that is nowhere near as good as original. If not, sub par or worse.

GR was pretty much a more proggy BWP

Album Rating: 3.5

"Even if it is, doing a rehash of that album would essentially be that: A rehash. It would not be nearly as good as the original. Trying too hard to duplicate an album usually leads to an album that is nowhere near as good as original. If not, sub par or worse."



Reference Dream Theaters ADTOE

Agreed and I liked that album.

Album Rating: 3.5

It's interesting that you think that Heritage sounds thin because of the vintage production when I think it's quite the opposite.

"GR is nowhere near as good as BWP tho"

It isnt far off actually

"GR was pretty much a more proggy BWP"

Nope, and it wasn't much proggier anyway. This is more proggier for example.

Album Rating: 5.0

Agreed.

Album Rating: 3.5

GR is tied with BWP if not slightly better than BWP. Will have to revisit both for a final judgement

Album Rating: 3.5

Album Rating: 4.0

GR > BWP but only slightly. GR is more varied but the title track of this tops everything

Album Rating: 3.5

BWP is a brutal track agreed

Album Rating: 4.0

lol yeah meant BWP

BWP title track >>>>

Album Rating: 3.5

Than?

most things. And all the songs in this album.

Album Rating: 4.0

than any other Opeth song tbh. but BWP album is only my 4th fav Opeth

GR is nowhere near as good as BWP tho