No album is perfect, but I'm pretty sure this is pretty close to as perfect as one can get

Album Rating: 5.0

@Nag in that case yeah I get you

@Sane backed hard

Album Rating: 5.0

Waters' vocals on Shine On are perfect [2]



this is the case with a lot of his singing for me. people harp on Roger's voice because it doesn't have traditionally aesthetically pleasing qualities like Dave's does...but it wouldn't fit a lot of the music imo..



a lot of PF's stuff that I love the most deals with mental illness/instability and just general discontentment or anger with different aspects of society, often employing heavy sarcasm as well to get that point across. for my $, no one ever has or probably ever will nail that tone like Roger.

Album Rating: 5.0

"That's a big assumption to make."



Go big or go home. Screw everybody and their little assumptions.

Album Rating: 5.0

By the way, it is possible to love imperfect things... which consist of everything on this planet. The album isn't perfect, but I love everything about it.

Album Rating: 4.5

love rogers voice, especially on animals

Album Rating: 4.5

BUS STOP RAT BAG HAHA CHARADE YOU ARE

YOU FUCKED UP OLD HAG HAHA CHARADE YOU ARE



His voice is perfect for that album.

Album Rating: 5.0

Yea, it's fucking solid.

Yeah Roger's vocals rule on Animals.

Although having said that Gilmour's vocals during the first half of Dogs are one of the highlights on the album for me, along with his solos on that song too of course.

Album Rating: 4.5

Agreed with that, Gilmour definitely could have sang the rest of Dogs without the end result bring much different. Pigs and

Sheep would've been worse of Gilmour sang them though IMO, wouldn't fit the music at all.

Album Rating: 5.0

No fucking way Gilmour's voice is perfect for the first half of Dogs and nothing about that can change

Album Rating: 4.5

I should've been clearer: GILMLOUR could have sang the rest of dogs, he nails the first halfamd his voice would have been MASSIVE in the "who was" climax.

Album Rating: 5.0

Ah right in that case agreed

this album

Album Rating: 5.0

This album is simply beautiful. Turn it on and lose yourself.

Album Rating: 5.0

Gilmores voice would not have been good for the end of dogs, like the firstcomment on this page says his voice doesn't

always fit as well as Rogers. Second half of dogs is way darker, the dramatic change in topic and voice is what makes

Dogs



Peanut butter and jelly yo

Album Rating: 4.5

The BBC doc on the making of this is superb and shows the fucking devastating unraveling of Syd. Greatest tribute album ever.

Album Rating: 4.0

Sounds awesome, will check.

That was on the other night, I didn't watch it as I've already seen it. Watched the Delicate Sound of Thunder concert film that was on though, hadn't seen that before.

Album Rating: 5.0

The BBC doc on the making of this is superb and shows the fucking devastating unraveling of Syd. Greatest tribute album ever.