Album Rating: 5.0

Watch it be an anomaly and the album will be For Those That Wish to Exist II

Album Rating: 4.0

Well this is heavier than anything off the new Architects sooo

Album Rating: 4.0

Swear to god if they write anything close to Rapture this album is gonna blow ahrd.



They need to expand on the new song with an album full of heavy jams it will definitely be higher than a 2.7

I mean ya, everyone’s already said it. Production’s blah, lyric’s are 11-year old atheistcore, but leagues better than erase me so *gestures vaguely*

idk, they’re borrowing aesthetics from disambig which is fine but compositionally it’s still pretty weak…maybe they had to let spencer have his lil go and the rest of whatever this is’ll be a return to form

Album Rating: 4.0

Love how everyone is bumping this thread and not the Erase Me one. That says it all really

Album Rating: 5.0

Well ya I wanna bump a good oath album lol

New track sounds like a neutered version of Illuminator with a weak groove riff in the first half and not great production

Don’t wanna be too negative but I’m still very skeptical

Album was cheeks, guy.

Album Rating: 4.0

True lol just funny cause people usually bump the most recent album when a new one is announced

Album Rating: 5.0

I AM THE ANCHOR

The Anchor Song is their best song probably.

New song is pretty solid. I'm liking how raw it sounds.

Album Rating: 1.5

BOUND TO MY EXISTENCE



I think Catch Myself is my favorite off here, but that one is close.

@JayEnder Lol, mhm. Collective trauma bonding.

Album Rating: 4.5

Spencer's lyrics were better when he was a Christian

Album Rating: 5.0

Props to Steak for the disam bump. Let's pretend Erase me didnt happen.



Real talk though after the single I decided to listen to EM again and its actually worse than I remembered

Album Rating: 5.0

ya shout out to me :]

Album Rating: 4.5

even as a nonreligious person who went through a similar ideological shift, these new lyrics are garbage. they read more like rants from a YouTube skeptic community video circa 2011 than any kind of meaningful take on doubt or loss of faith.



like on Erase Me I kinda gave the lyrics a pass, cause it seemed like a raw nerve for Spencer and he probably had a lot of pent up anger and emotion.



now we're 5 years on and it's the same thing, except it feels less genuine.

Album Rating: 4.0

Erase Me sucks horribly yeah.

Album Rating: 5.0

Erase Me was fine...

Album Rating: 4.5

Sure, if you don't care about Underoath not sounding like Underoath and like that kind of crap.