Album Rating: 5.0

Yea sheep was amazing

Sheep is incredible but Dogs is just on a whole other level.

Album Rating: 4.7

Love Dogs, Gilmour > obviously, but I just love the extended vocal notes on Sheep, best Roger vocals imo. Plus, THAT guitar climax.

Album Rating: 4.5

Sheep is shorter and sweeter. As much as I love Dogs and think it has some of the best moments of the album, its not as consistent at delivering as Sheep is if that makes any sense

Album Rating: 4.7

Yeah agreed, Dogs would've been better off without Roger's vocals at the end whereas I wouldn't really change anything about Sheep.

Album Rating: 4.5

I actually really like the ending of Dogs, one of the best parts (the lyrics are incredibly haunting

there). Its the drawn out interludes between the verses that coulda been hacked imo

Album Rating: 4.7

Oh yeah the ending itself is fantastic, I wasn't saying it should be cut, I just would've preferred if

Gilmour had sung the whole song rather than Waters taking over on the end bit.

Album Rating: 4.5

Gilmour sings like an angel so I can't deny that. Roger just fits so well in certain parts of songs

(Comfortably Numb, Beginning of Dogs, SOYCD, etc) and is clearly a better candidate

Dogs is perfect imo. My favourite Floyd song.

Album Rating: 4.7

"Roger just fits so well in certain parts of songs

(Comfortably Numb, Beginning of Dogs, SOYCD, etc) and is clearly a better candidate"

I agree he fits well in certain parts but he sucks hard in others. A better candidate for what?



@Jamie Yeah I know a lot of people feel that way but idk I just reckon they've done better in their time.

Album Rating: 5.0

Rowan ya boat

Album Rating: 5.0

Gilmour sings the first half of dogs.

Album Rating: 4.7

I know that, Triple B. What'd you call me mate?

Album Rating: 5.0

Rowan ya boat buddy as in Rowing your Boat...lame I know.

Album Rating: 4.7

ahhhhhh sigh. Why did you say Gilmour sings the first half of Dogs? I never said otherwise.

Album Rating: 5.0

I was talking to The Space Man bro

Album Rating: 4.7

I'm confused, you posted about me and then talked to him lol. Why you no specify intended message receiver man?

Album Rating: 5.0

"I still can't get over how awesome the part in Sheep where Gilmour's vocals fade into the synthesizer is"

'Waters' vocals dude, but agreed it's immense.'



Sweet, yeah I was under the impression that it was Gimour not Wright, just thought it sounded like him imo

Album Rating: 5.0

Because I'm mysterious.

Album Rating: 4.7

@wack Nah it's definitely Waters bro but yeah I agree that it doesn't really sound like Waters, probably because it's a lot better than he normally sounds lol.



@BBB You shifty character you.