I don't see why this is so hard to believe. This trumps everything I've ever heard from them, especially Division which I think is their weakest album.

The Autumn Effect I loved for the atmospheric and tranquil feel of their rock.

Killing All That Holds You I loved for its just plain awesomeness

This mixes everything i love about 10 Years and adds more elements to the bag.

Album Rating: 3.5

P#1>WWN >S-FC>TTOT(CDUI)>VS



I highly disagree although i still respect your opinion. To me its WWN

Album Rating: 3.5

Alright, I'll respect LG too.

Album Rating: 3.5

P#1 - quirky, still exploring their influences and finding themselves.



WWN -Found selves and try to tear your face off with it. Dark and heavy.



TTOT(CDUI) - This might be my favorite album by them, I listened to this album over and over and over...



VS - This album is an odd experience, kinda between worlds, I guess. After their first album, they downtuned more and more each album, this broke the mold, guess it's the stepping stone to Sci-Fi crimes. It's a grower, the songs on here ARE great.



S-FC - Artsy and fun. People say they never changed, from album to album, and are kinda stale now. Noooo. This is different, it was good to see them not stagnating.



My unnecessary commentary, as if asked. Also, I don't know which is my favorite, but it's not Point # 1. Although... "SMA" is incredible.

Album Rating: 3.0

P#1 - Raw Albini production, aggressive, diverse, Helmet homage



WWN - Refined aggression, darker and slicker, contains some of their best songs to this day



TTOT(CDUI) - Even moodier than WWN, while less consistent it still gives a fresh feel after WWN



VS - Idk, I just find it to be WWN pt. 2, except less exciting. I still like it, but it's my least favorite.



S-FC - Fresh, it rejuvenates their sound, it feels more energetic and hopeful.

Album Rating: 3.5

I like your summaries, they're pretty accurate. Except I don't think VS is WWN 2, not dark enough, or something. Different feel.

Album Rating: 3.0

Idk, I guess I meant more that it feels like they were playing it safe.. not a lot of structural change.





That being said, Antisaint rules

Album Rating: 3.5

Ah, yeah, I agree. It's by far the safest feeling of their albums. And I agree, "Antisaint" was great. The bonus track "Sleepwalking Elite" was rad, too.



So, on this 10 Years album, did I hear him say "antisaints" in one of the songs? I think I read it was "anti fates" on a site, or two, but it sounded like "antisaints" to me....

Album Rating: 3.0

dunno, only listened to it once.



What're your 3 favorite 10 years songs? (assuming you heard their albums)

Album Rating: 3.5

Oh, absolutely I have. Let's see.... No order: "Waking Up", "Russian Roulette", and...... Uhm... Damn, this is hard. Between "The Recipe", "Cast It Out", "Actions & Motives" and "Dead in The Water"...



I'm a HORRIBLY fickle favorite chooser, but those I just mentioned are most commonly the ones I'd say. I... think.



You?

Album Rating: 3.0

I'd have to pick 5





Through the Iris, Focus, Russian Roulette, Half Life, All Your Lies







....I think.

Album Rating: 3.5

It's frigging difficult to choose, huh? Also, "Through The Iris" and "Focus" I considered for my list, as well.

Album Rating: 3.0

yea kinda hard to choose. my favorites depend on my mood at the time.

Album Rating: 3.5

Exactly, exactly. Same goes for which album I want to listen to more, really. They write a lot of good material.

Both of your opinions are null, for not rating this a four or higher.

Wasteland
Proud of You
Half-Life
Dying Youth
The Recipe

Album Rating: 3.5

Wasteland

11am: Daydreamer

Actions & Motives

Prey

Through The Iris

Album Rating: 3.5

I intentionally missed it. probably should have gone into a Chevelle thread.

Album Rating: 3.5

Totally agree about Chevelle and 10 Years leading this genre.

Top 5 10 years songs

- Shoot it out

- Waking up

- Actions and motives

- Cast it out

-11am

Album Rating: 3.5

Finally some love for 11am.