Album Rating: 1.5

Oh shit that seems a little harsh

lmao is that because you hate thursday or think this is a bad thursday album?

Album Rating: 4.0

Kids only like full collapse and war all the time and don't really care about their other albums. Which is a shame because I think that makes Geoff ashamed of them.

Album Rating: 4.5

the 3 albums after those two >>>>>>> those two

kids don't know shit

Album Rating: 4.0

Waiting is also overlooked hard.

Album Rating: 4.0

And yeah, I kinda hate their fans

Waiting is a gem and gets unfairly + incorrectly written off as de facto worst thursday
i guess War is probs in their top 2, so at least the fans got something right

Album Rating: 4.4

Waiting rules and the mix on War is so fucking bad it knocks it out of top 3. pretty sure I could've mixed that album better on my phone

haha most cool hip kids have brick phones
rowan has a brickwall

Album Rating: 4.0

City divided is their weakest to me but that's largely because it's all over the place. People think this is a grower, I'd show them that.



I'm pretty sure war and collapse are so popular because they're Thursday at their heaviest. Which isn't what I'd call their defining trait but w/e

Album Rating: 4.0

War is awesome live but the album sounds so held back I have no idea why. Can't properly explain it either. Doesn't feel as powerful as it should.

Album Rating: 4.5

war is good but kinda inconsistent and i dont dig the production at all



then again my favorite is city and that seems to be what the general consensus is on that one

Album Rating: 4.0

Same producer between albums too. I don't think the band were in the best place with each other so maybe a lot just got overlooked? That's an album that could use a remaster. The title track off that should be one of their best songs but it just isn't done enough justice.

Album Rating: 4.4

the production on City is pretty rough, just compare the Telegraph demo to the final album version - completely sucked the life out of it. Autumn Leaves and Sugar in the Sacrament are bangers tho

Album Rating: 4.0

At this velocity is basically a united nation's song.

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, I heard that Geoff wanted City to sound like the UN debut. That would have been a crazy direction for Thursday to take. I love UN, but I'm glad they pursued the moodier direction. City is not my favourite but this one and No Dev are just stellar. I agree that it's a shame their reunion tours have so heavily focused on their 2nd/3rd records because to me their whole discography deserves to be celebrated. I would just as happily fork out for a No Dev show as a Full Collapse show tbh.

Album Rating: 4.4

I would be so bummed if I went to a Thursday show and they only played Full Collapse songs lmao. it's a good album but they evolved so far past it

Album Rating: 4.5

They lean super heavy on Full Collapse and War. Only ever a few other token tracks. Just glad that Turnpike Divides seems to still be a staple.

Album Rating: 4.5

War has always been my favorite Thursday album with Full Collapse hitting in at second but I do still feel like the other albums get overshadowed by the vast majority of fans despite how well received they all are on sites like this.



I know Geoff has said before that he really likes this album and found it to be a shame that the album didnt resonate with fans as much as it did for him.