Album Rating: 3.5

wrong again....ive listened to mellon collie more than this up to the present day.....cant even compare the songwriting, diversity, flow, etc......25 of those songs are better than at least half of this album

Ars I meant high on Ween : )

dude you seem genuinely really chill rn, you seem like you're only cool when you're drunk so i fgured you were drunk, like a really sassy uncle or something

"25 of those songs are better than at least half of this album"

holy fuck how many songs are on mellon collie?

I cannot really relate to this band so far idk why

god this shit frustrates me more than any album ever

more than fucking elliott smith

what the fuck

28 songs I think..its 2 hrs lol

Album Rating: 5.0

"holy fuck how many songs are on mellon collie?"



28

jesus fuck this stupid ass record so frustrating so many good songs so many mediocre ones wtf

Album Rating: 5.0

Believe it or not, I actually wasn't incredibly fond of this album when I first heard it either. Most people I talk to say they loved it immediately, but I wasn't even close to that, lol

Album Rating: 5.0

'twas a hell of a grower

No no, fuck that remain in light memee


i've heard this too many times, billy corgan is just a pretentious nob

Album Rating: 3.5

ala dude mellon collie is so much better than this

Album Rating: 5.0

Mellon Collie is great, but it has a handful of songs I don't like, which this does not

Album Rating: 3.5

not only is it better, it also has their best song ever which is none other than Tonight, Tonight

Album Rating: 5.0

Billy might be a pretentious nob, but he's a pretentious nob who makes badass tunes (unlike Oasis, who are pretentious nobs who couldn't make a good album to save their lives)

"Billy might be a pretentious nob, but he's a pretentious nob who makes badass tunes (unlike Oasis, who are pretentious nobs who couldn't make a good album to save their lives)"

You went from "tunes" to "album". Nice switcheroo there pal

DUDE TITAN TONIGHT TONIGHT IS A CHILDHOOD FAVORITE

Album Rating: 5.0

" You went from "tunes" to "album". Nice switcheroo there pal"



Is there a problem with that? Am I missing something here?

"Is there a problem with that? Am I missing something here? "

yeah. I said the dude was a pretentious nob and you said "at least he can makes tunes" but then critcized oasis for making bad albums

my rating for this a 2.5 so by your logic he's as bad

Album Rating: 5.0

I'm not sure how that makes any sense. All I said is that Billy is pretentious but makes good music. Then I compared him with Oasis (ESPECIALLY Liam), who are equally pretentious but suck way harder and don't have the songwriting to back them up. That's simply what I was saying