i was gonna say that

I'd kill myself if that were the case.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

This album's 5 rating (which should not equal classic, but whatever) is based almost entirely off of replay value, not technicality or "emotion" or ambiance or whatever. This is literally an album I can throw on anytime and listen to it completely; one of very few, I might add.

Well get out the noose, Mr. Pit because that's certainly the case. Never mind the plethora of amazing albums that came out before ... In Shallow Seas, I haven't even heard those but I don't need to to know that they don't hold a candle to Emery. And in the wise words of Emim on the last page-
"I mean, I don't listen to Glassjaw or AtD-I nearly as much as this."
Period.

I feel a need to edit Davey's summary:

Emery's latest IS post-hardcore's finest ever!

Anybody who disagrees is a book-reading elitist!



ok sorry I'm done now

That's a pretty ridiculous statement, Emim.

Album Rating: 4.5

hahahaha, book reading elitist.



Fuck you guys and your books...



*...slowly puts away the book he is reading...*

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Being as it is the truth, I don't see how.



Can you really ridicule someone's taste because they don't like what you like as much as you like it??? While the answer is obviously yes for you two, should you?

No, I'm ridiculing it because all good music that has replay value has emotion, otherwise you wouldn't be replaying it.

Album Rating: 4.5

no, they're ridiculing you because they think that their musical taste eclipses yours, because they write reviews for music on the interwebz.



not even trying to start shit but some of you guys take music way too seriously. Listen to what you like, and don't listen to what you don't like. horray for common sense fella's!

It's the word "classic" that deters people from rating an album 5/5 I think. That automatically suggests the album will go down in history or some shit like that.

But fuck all that; you take an album, load it with perfect songs, barely any filler, and you give that album a 5/5, that's how I do it.

Album Rating: 5.0

^wooord, the replay value of this album is otherwordly seriously a great album

but this has no perfect songs and tons of filler

Yeah, that's your opinion. You already know mine is the complete opposite.

Album Rating: 5.0

sea i cant belive you rated hey monday's latest higher than this one, i mean c'mon this album is way better man, even at its lowest it is

nothing against you guys at all you take it too personally, I just see this album as the downfall of so much good music... it took good shit and dumbed it down and perverted it into this ugly hybrid of horribleness... compounded with the fact that the music at hand is shitty too.

it's nothing against the fans at all, I'm just post-hardcore's humble savior-- crying out for help in the fight against a genre gone bad like milk that's been left in the fridge too long and got all crusty.

^amen brother.


Amen.

Album Rating: 4.5

but...but, what if I like old school Post-hardcore...

and the dumbed down garbage new post-hardcore...?



does that mean, I'm like...half of a dumb ass?

Album Rating: 3.5

Ewww I hate bad milk. But this album is good.

@ PinkBlackberry: YES

Album Rating: 4.5

Dammit



I'm going to go kill myself now, brb.

Hurry up, we want to see how bad it is.