Album Rating: 3.0

'i prefer unforgiven 3. That’s such a great solo'



actually, yeah i agree. somehow forgot about that one.

Album Rating: 3.5

^ Pretty sure I mentioned this in the DM thread, but that part where James screams "why can't I FORGIVE ME???" and then that long guitar bend comes in... man, it gives me goosebumps everytime

we need unforgiven 4 on their final album coming full circle, would rock so hard

It would be called UnforgIVen and have some corny lyrics like "what am I unforgiven for" or something like that, I'd bet.

Album Rating: 3.5

And then it'll finish with the line "wait, actually I was wrong. I dub thee forgiven"

Album Rating: 2.5

not so bad

Album Rating: 3.5

Moth Into Flame still goes

Album Rating: 3.5

Yes, one of the very best here

Album Rating: 2.5

yea probably best song here

Album Rating: 3.0

Decided to revisit this after listening to the new Megadeth and wow, I never quite put two and two together regarding just how much better a guitarist Mustane is to these guys.

haha! i'd hold up dave to any other guitarist really. skill, precision, feel, memorability. he's got it all. all while singing. i will never get how he can play holy wars and sing lol

Album Rating: 3.0

Not that this thread is relevant anymore, but after relistening to this after nearly a decade, here's a track ranking:



1. Halo on Fire

2. Atlas, Rise!

3. Spit Out the Bone

4. Moth into Flame

5. Dream No More

6. Am I Savage?

7. Confusion

8. ManUNkind

9. Murder One

10. Hardwired

11. Here Comes Revenge

12. Now That We're Dead



I'd be tempted to bump this to a 3.5, but the lack of any memorable solos, tepid drumming, inaudible bass, and daunting length really detract from the album experience. No hot takes.

Album Rating: 3.5

ngl Lars cooked with that one fill in moth into flame