I love personal reviews

I think underoath lost their faith

Album Rating: 2.0

REM did

Album Rating: 2.5

"Everything Belongs" and "Hold Up a Light" are complete garbage. The rest of the album is stellar.

Album Rating: 2.5

Yeah I'm waiting for "Everything Belongs" to grow on me, it's just alright. "Hold Up a Light" is pretty good even though it's repetitive af.

Ditto

I keep swinging my knob through a swarm of bees

Haven't commented on a review in a while but I just wanted to say I really like what you have to say. There are some criticisms and questions here that I'd never really considered as strongly as you seem to have. Great write-up, I am interested to see how you will feel about their next album.

Album Rating: 3.0

Guys a few synth lines and like 5 seconds of a harp on one song really doesnt make this that experimental :/

Album Rating: 3.0

This is at least better than that new Underoath album at least.

Album Rating: 4.0

"This is at least better than that new Underoath album at least."



At least.

Album Rating: 2.5

I fucking hate Hold Up A Light

band has been trash since alchemy

Album Rating: 2.0

Idk about trash but yeah vheissu was their last album I was able to fully get into

Album Rating: 3.0

This band has always bored the shit out of me

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

I know how stupid this is, but the fact that someone whose musical opinions I respect, like Sowing, genuinely enjoys this album actually has a little bit of positive influence on my opinion of this album.



It’s like the exact opposite of when I watch a Needle Drop review of an album that I like, but the review points out some subpar stuff that I hadn’t noticed until I’d watched said video review.

I had one listen and wasn't offended or impressed. I'm gonna go backwards thru their discography and see how I feel, Halfway thru To Be Everywhere Is to Be Nowhere and I forgot how good that album was and how much energy was there. That is kinda what is missing from this one, also Dustin's vocals somehow seem smoother than a couple years ago which seems odd.

Album Rating: 3.0

This is the first time I've been disappointed by a Thrice release in the 16 years I've been listening to them. I'm not sure what Dustin was thinking with some of these lyrics and Hold Up a Light might be the worst song they've ever put out that wasn't a B-Side. I hope it grows on me but so far it's been the opposite.



Only Us 4/5

The Grey 3.5/5

The Dark 3.5/5

Just Breathe 5/5

Everything Belongs 3.5/5

My Soul 3/5

A Branch in the River 3/5

Hold Up a Light 1.5/5

Blood on Blood 5/5

Beyond the Pines 5/5

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

i'm super into this on an objective basis, but for whatever fucking reason i've gotten onto a random Travis Scott kick this week and i'm having a hard time appreciating any music that's not Rodeo or Astroworld right now

give me a week or so and i'll be in a full-blown Thrice kick, but yall just gotta let me get this trap out of my system

Am i the only one who thinks the production is shite?